|
A - I n f o s
|
|
a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists
**
News in all languages
Last 40 posts (Homepage)
Last two
weeks' posts
Our
archives of old posts
The last 100 posts, according
to language
Greek_
中文 Chinese_
Castellano_
Catalan_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
_The.Supplement
The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours |
of past 30 days |
of 2002 |
of 2003 |
of 2004 |
of 2005 |
of 2006 |
of 2007 |
of 2008 |
of 2009 |
of 2010 |
of 2011 |
of 2012 |
of 2013 |
of 2014 |
of 2015 |
of 2016 |
of 2017 |
of 2018 |
of 2019 |
of 2020 |
of 2021 |
of 2022 |
of 2023 |
of 2024 |
of 2025 |
of 2026
Syndication Of A-Infos - including
RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups
(en) Italy, FAI, Umanita Nova #28-26 - Incitement to cure. Medicine under racist attack from the government. (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
Date
Sun, 15 Nov 2026 08:10:28 +0200
With this article, the Collettive Brigate Basaglia expresses its full
solidarity with colleagues, male and female, and others under
investigation for what should be the simplest and most natural gesture
in medicine: looking at a person before looking at their documents,
listening to their suffering before looking at their administrative
status, recognizing a human being before looking at a legal category.
Yes, that's right: the Ravenna Public Prosecutor's Office recently
investigated over 20 healthcare professionals across Italy
(approximately 23-24 doctors) on charges of issuing false certificates
of unfitness to prevent the detention of irregular migrants in CPRs
(Repatriation Detention Centers) .
Perhaps this was all that was missing. After the crime of solidarity,
after the crime of rescue at sea, or of those who cross a border without
permission or without a sufficiently substantial bank account, finally
comes the new great danger to Italian public order: the incitement to
treatment!
Because if medical personnel dare to do what medicine should exist
for-look at a person, listen to their suffering, assess their
vulnerability-then perhaps something in the "democratic" institutional
machinery has jammed.
But perhaps the deeper issue isn't just about CPRs, medical personnel,
or a single judicial proceeding. It concerns an even larger problem, the
very existence of administrative or detention structures built around
the absurd idea that some human beings might find themselves out of
place (especially if they're poor).
But out of place compared to what? Compared to a line drawn on a map by
four bureaucrats. Compared to a border established in history. Compared
to a document that establishes who can move freely (especially if
they're rich) and who must continually prove their right to be
somewhere. The war on poor migrants waged by governments everywhere is
also a reality for "European democracy," not a mistake along the way!
The problem isn't just the inhumane way these concentration camps,
defined as "administrative" facilities, are managed, about which we've
already said enough. The problem is the very principle by which a human
being can become irregular, invisible, suspended, simply because they
were born on the other side of a border, or because they're "poor," or
because they're not white enough, or not Christian enough.
Even before the CPRs, this cursed doctrine existed: that the world is
divided into territories belonging to nation-states, and that within
these territories some people are considered legitimate, while others
are temporarily tolerated, controllable, and expelled.
It is precisely within this inhumane logic that the deepest
contradiction arises, where medicine is called upon to certify not
health, but a person's ability to tolerate a condition that can damage
their health. Indeed, as widely stated by the "Never Again Concentration
Camps - NO to CPRs" network, which includes some of the accused doctors,
the pathogenicity-that is, the capacity-of these detention centers to
cause disease and harm is now recognized. Indeed, simply staying in a
CPR, due to the profoundly harmful conditions documented and witnessed,
can lead to serious health problems. This is sadly ironic, considering
that by legislative definition, in these centers "foreigners must be
held in ways that ensure the necessary assistance and full respect for
their dignity."
It's no longer enough for a person to be deprived of their liberty in a
CPR. It's no longer enough for their body to be inserted into an
administrative apparatus designed to facilitate expulsion. Now that body
must also be declared compatible with this absurd and inhumane
condition; repression thus forces medicine to collaborate with all of this.
And here the paradox emerges. Medicine should ask a very simple clinical
question: what does this person need to get better?
But that's not enough! In these contexts, medicine itself is also called
upon to ask further questions, political questions: can this person be
forced into the inhumane machinery the central government has designed
for them without creating too many problems? Can we make them invisible
and let them die within the institutional democracy of Fortress Europe
without raising too much dust, and indeed, even picking up a few votes
on their body?
The recent case, which sees other clinicians investigated across Italy
(alongside those in Ravenna earlier this year) for certifying the
unsuitability of some migrants destined for CPRs, isn't just a matter of
legal proceedings. It concerns a much broader question: what role is
assigned to medicine within a society that calls itself democratic?
Should doctors be the person's guarantor or an administrative cog in
charge of making a detention system work?
Official data from the World Health Organization have repeatedly
highlighted how the administrative detention of migrants poses a risk to
mental and physical health, especially when combined with isolation,
uncertainty about the future, previous traumatic experiences, and
difficult environmental conditions.
Medicine cannot be called upon simply to verify whether a body is
resistant enough to withstand a pathological condition. Otherwise,
doctors no longer treat the damage: they certify the body's capacity to
endure it.
And this is precisely where the issue becomes political. Because if a
place is a source of suffering, the healthcare response shouldn't be to
increase people's capacity to endure it within that place. The
healthcare response should question the very existence of that place.
CPRs are not hospitals. They are not therapeutic facilities. They are
places of deprivation of liberty. Their peculiarity is precisely this: a
person can be deprived of liberty without having committed a criminal
offense, but because they are in an administratively deemed irregular
situation. Yet, the human body does not distinguish between a cell
called a prison and a closed room called a detention center. The body
knows only concrete experience: the cursed isolation from everyone and
everything, the loss of control over one's life, the inability to
choose, the fear of expulsion, the suspension of one's future.
Over the years, numerous incidents of self-harm, attempted suicides, and
suicides have emerged within CPRs. The case of Ousmane Sylla, who
committed suicide in the Ponte Galeria CPR in 2024, has become a symbol
of the critical issues related to mental health in the centers. This is
not a marginal detail.
In prison medicine, self-harm is not simply an individual behavior, but
often represents a clear communication signal of a context that is
producing suffering. When so many people, within the same environment,
express desperation, the question has no excuse, and it can't simply be
"how to control these people." The question should be: what is this
environment doing to the people who are placed there?
Another disturbing factor concerns the flood of psychotropic drugs
within CPRs. Several independent reports and observations have
highlighted the significant use of sedatives and psychotropic drugs in
CPRs. Naturally, each pharmacological treatment should be evaluated on a
case-by-case basis and may indeed be necessary in the presence of
specific clinical conditions.
But there is a more general question: when a person suffers because they
are placed in an environment that produces anguish, fear, and a loss of
control, is the response to sedation the person, or to modify the entire
environment that generates that suffering?
The history of psychiatry has taught us precisely this: for decades, we
have called "individual illness" what was often also, and above all, the
product of institutions, social relationships, and inhumane and
oppressive living conditions.
Basaglia clearly demonstrated this. The problem was not only mental
suffering, but the way a society decided to organize the response to
that suffering.
The issue of CPR doctors is therefore a question of ethics, even before
it is a judicial one. Doctors are not called upon to certify that a
system works; they are called upon to evaluate a person. The difference
seems small, but it changes everything. When administrative logic
becomes dominant, the risk is that health care becomes a mere technical
requirement: a stamp necessary for a bureaucratic procedure to proceed.
But medicine shouldn't be a practice of adapting bodies to the cursed
demands of institutions. Medicine should remind institutions that there
are limits that no administrative procedure can erase. Medicine has
never been neutral, we know that. Throughout history, it has repeatedly
become an instrument of classification, exclusion, control, and
violence, especially against socially oppressed groups, such as women
and racialized individuals. On the contrary, there have been times when
it has instead chosen the side of the individual against the establishment.
Doctors who falsified documents to save lives during Fascism. Doctors
who denounced the violence in mental hospitals. Health workers who,
during the G8 in Genoa, treated people injured during protests,
regardless of any other considerations, precisely because medical ethics
has always included the right to care for the individual, whoever they
may be.
Perhaps one day, the issue won't be remembered as "the case of the
doctors who obstructed CPRs." Perhaps it will be remembered as the
moment when a society had to choose whether medicine should serve
bodies, or the "democratic and human rights-conscious" European
mechanisms built to govern bodies.
And here lies the paradox. In a system where suffering is administered
and administered, those who attempt to cure it risk becoming the
problem. And then, yes, perhaps the day will truly come when we will
have to defend ourselves from the new crime of incitement to treatment.
In fact, it has already arrived.
The fault? Having continued to see human beings where others saw
practices to be disposed of. But our tolerance ends there!
We are tired of witnessing yet another abuse of authoritarian logic
within structures that call themselves democratic, yet continue to
permit and promote forms of violence, control, and oppression over the
most vulnerable.
So care alone is not enough! Care cannot simply mean addressing pain
once it has already been produced. Care also means jointly recognizing
what generates that pain, naming it, addressing it, and building bonds
that prevent it from being continually reproduced. This is why care must
become collective action.
Today, it is no longer enough for medical personnel to simply say, "I
won't sign," as Basaglia said on his first day as director of the
Gorizia mental hospital in 1961. Responsibility cannot be left to the
individual doctor faced with a certificate to sign. If the problem is
structural, the response must be structural too.
We ask all clinics and clinicians, activists, and anyone who continues
to believe in human dignity, to break down these bureaucratic cages in
the way they deem most appropriate.
Let's plant care bombs everywhere. Bombs that don't explode, but rather
open cracks in the walls of indifference. Bombs made of solidarity,
presence, mutual aid, professional disobedience, and shared
responsibility. Bombs that symbolically burn useless documents, those
categories and procedures that don't protect people, but only serve to
separate them, classify them, make them expelable and less human. Bombs
that symbolically blow up those bureaucratic chains that only serve to
create artificial boundaries between human beings.
We must destroy nothing, except the idea, peddled by institutions, that
one person can be considered less human than another.
What should explode is the love we hold within us, which allows us to
recognize in another person not an administrative problem, but a life, a
loving heart, which instead is dying in a cell a stone's throw from our
home.
Care isn't just what happens between a professional and a person. Care
also happens when a community decides that no one should be left alone
in the face of oppressive power. It happens when a doctor refuses to
sign what he deems unjust and other doctors stand by him. It happens
when an activist reports abuse and other people ensure that her report
isn't stifled. It happens when we transform solidarity from a private
sentiment to an organized practice.
We must not let anything explode, except the oppressive silence, the
devastating renunciation that surrounds us and kills us from within.
What must explode is the collective capacity to care for one another.
Because when care becomes collective, it ceases to be merely assistance
and becomes resistance, and when this resistance pulsates, vibrating
with a widespread feeling of freedom, it becomes revolution!
Let's not let these words end up only on this paper!
Let's write letters to our professional associations, if that's the tool
we have at our disposal. Let's write on millions of other sheets of
paper, let's write on our bodies, on walls, on streets, on doors and
gates! Let's make our voices heard, let's shout, but let's shout loudly!
Let's release the pain, let's release the humanity repressed by the
bureaucracy of totalitarian institutions. Let's organize in the
workplace. Let's build networks between professionals and friends. Let's
make contradictions public. Let's support those who speak out. Let's not
leave alone those who refuse to transform their profession into an
administrative cog. But let's do it with heart and calm anger! We are
not alone! Solidarity.
Basaglia Brigades
https://umanitanova.org/istigazione-alla-cura-la-medicina-sotto-lattacco-razzista-del-governo/
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
- Prev by Date:
(de) France, Monde Libertaire - IDEEN UND KÄMPFE: Konvergierende Kämpfe (ca, en, it, fr, pt, tr)[maschinelle Übersetzung]
- Next by Date:
(en) France, SocLib: THE 3 TYPES OF GENERAL STRIKE: UTILITARIAN, SOLIDARITY-BASED, AND REVOLUTIONARY (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
A-Infos Information Center