|
A - I n f o s
|
|
a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists
**
News in all languages
Last 40 posts (Homepage)
Last two
weeks' posts
Our
archives of old posts
The last 100 posts, according
to language
Greek_
中文 Chinese_
Castellano_
Catalan_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
_The.Supplement
The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours |
of past 30 days |
of 2002 |
of 2003 |
of 2004 |
of 2005 |
of 2006 |
of 2007 |
of 2008 |
of 2009 |
of 2010 |
of 2011 |
of 2012 |
of 2013 |
of 2014 |
of 2015 |
of 2016 |
of 2017 |
of 2018 |
of 2019 |
of 2020 |
of 2021 |
of 2022 |
of 2023 |
of 2024 |
of 2025 |
of 2026
Syndication Of A-Infos - including
RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups
(en) France, OCL: READ: A handbook against academic failure (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
Date
Fri, 6 Nov 2026 07:31:33 +0200
Can there be a "school of emancipation"? Nicolas Kaczmarek, a history
and geography teacher in a priority education network (REP+) middle
school and a member of the Research Group on School Democratization
(GRDS), believes so, and in his Handbook Against School Failure
(published by La Dispute, 2026), he outlines its contours. While I
disagree-in part-with the author's analysis of the school system (1), as
well as with the societal project he defends (see the last part of this
article), I believe this book contains valuable elements for pedagogical
reflection and for critiquing the school system, both for its
professionals and its users.
What project for the school?
A school of emancipation would be "a school of intellectual rigor for
all, placed at the service of free, self-sufficient knowledge. A school
that relies on the joy of understanding as its daily driving force. A
school that reveals its codes and objectives, that embraces dialogue so
as not to trap or manipulate anyone. A school where everyone succeeds. A
school of the 'refusal to succeed,' that refuses to be reduced to an
economic end, a school that equips students for emancipation" (p. 45).
Far from the "grinding machine" that is the current school system, this
school, "revolutionized" by the critical "radicalism" that the author
opposes to it, would also prove to be "common: a polytechnic school
valuing a variety of knowledge within a single core curriculum up to the
age of 18" (pp. 146-147). This project, championed with the GRDS and
embodied in the demand for a step towards extending school
"democratization" to the comprehensive high school system, following the
comprehensive middle school system, is not new (2). However, in N.
Kaczmarek's vision, it fits not within the abolition of wage labor and
employers, so dear to the revolutionary syndicalist movement, but within
the perspective of a lifetime salary "based on personal qualifications"
(note 4, p. 13) advocated by Bernard Friot and the Wage Labor Network
(3). This would free schools from the need to align with the job market,
and thus put an end to career guidance, synonymous with social sorting.
The objective is also to "save democracy" because, by strengthening
equality for all in education, one combats "educational stratification,"
which "contributes to the emergence of a greater acceptance of
inequality in our society" (p. 149), and the vote for the National Rally
(4). In short, teachers should provide students with the critical
knowledge that allows them to "become aware[...]of the power relations
that run through our society, from the classroom to relations between
states, so that they want to free our world from relations of
domination" (p. 14).
"But since we cannot wait for society to change before schools change as
well, I propose in this book a set of reflections and concrete classroom
practices to move, within the current system, towards this common
school" (p. 14). To enable all students to succeed-that is, to "reach an
academic level that avoids the need to discuss 'tracking' before the age
of eighteen"-traditional union demands for class size reduction would
not be sufficient, and, according to the author, based on research, some
teaching methods are "more effective" than others (p. 41). N. Kaczmarek
thus takes a stand in the "minefield" of the educational debate, drawing
on research that distances itself from "certain practices considered
emancipatory but which show little effectiveness in the development and
transmission of knowledge and skills" (active learning, differentiated
instruction, etc., p. 41). The success of this pedagogy remains
"dependent on its extension beyond a single individual practice[...]by
the whole of a school or establishment" (p. 49).
The possibilities of pedagogy
N. Kaczmarek immediately dismisses the simplistic explanations for the
academic failure of the working-class children he teaches daily,
explanations endlessly repeated by teachers: "lack of motivation or
involvement, lack of homework, problems with memorization" (p. 51). On
the other hand, what characterizes students from working-class
backgrounds is "the diminished capacity to create[...]the illusion of
genuine understanding," an expected objective of school, which does not
seek to truly make students understand the content of the lesson, but
rather to force them to "give the teacher the right words, at the right
time, in the best possible way" (pp. 52-53). Teachers, who employ these
pedagogical practices daily but are convinced they cannot be satisfied
with such superficiality, "refute a priori" this diagnosis "because it
is so difficult to accept" (p. 53).
Therefore, to lead all students to a true understanding not only of the
knowledge, skills, and stakes of the subjects taught, but also of what
lies behind the meritocratic ideological veil that masks the class
violence of the so-called Republic's schools, the author then details
practices developed through many years of pedagogical experimentation
with his students (5). N. Kaczmarek constantly seeks to foster an active
stance among students in the classroom (of "high intellectual
activity"), in contrast to the passivity often observed in students who
simply copy "the written record" at the end of the lesson, "the only
thing to do to keep the peace and avoid any punishment" (p. 59). To this
end, he familiarizes students with problem-solving "inspired
by[his]university training" (p. 56), building their confidence "in their
ability to tackle major theoretical questions and ultimately experience
the joy of understanding" (p. 58). He forces them to take notes (rather
than dictating or distributing the lesson), for which "it is essential
to understand everything in order to synthesize and note in their own
way" (p. 61). He explains to them the difference between everyday
language and scientific language "which allows one to be more precise"
(p. 64), and, to ensure that the students are "able to explain each term
in the document", the teacher imposes a rule: "any word used in an
answer that does not belong to everyday language[...]must be explained
and therefore followed by 'that is to say...'" (pp. 80-81).
Furthermore, noting the vagueness of certain instructions, the teacher
undertook a project to define each verb used daily, which is now
displayed in the classroom as a tool students can use at any time during
the lesson, including during assessments (p. 93). In doing so, students
realize that a phase of analyzing the question is necessary (p. 96),
which helps to prevent spontaneous, often incorrect, responses (p. 101).
The most complex history and geography tasks (reading maps, writing
structured essays, analyzing tables or graphs) are broken down into
sub-tasks to avoid cognitive overload (p. 110). Adding to this the
preparation for the final assessment, discussed with the students, and
techniques for proofreading their work, allows the teacher to open the
pedagogical "black box" (p. 107): revealing the teacher's true
expectations and challenging the implicit assumptions of the institution.
Some criticisms
As a middle school teacher facing similar challenges to the author, I
share the pedagogical proposals of the Manual and their associated
objectives. Maintaining high expectations for working-class students and
adopting practices distinct from those aimed at "not holding back the
best students" (p. 21) is a delicate balancing act. So, while we wait
for the proletarian fury to sweep away the old world (and its schools
along with it), in the meantime, stuck together-teachers and
students-for a few hours a week in a classroom, on the one hand by wage
labor, on the other by compulsory schooling, we should make the most of
this alienated time-as much as possible-a moment of transparency, of
shared understanding (which doesn't mask the power dynamic or the true
objectives of the capitalist school system), and of transmitting the
most demanding intellectual tools possible. The author's proposals
address real observations (organized academic failure for social
sorting, pedagogical and meritocratic illusions, etc.), and I can only
echo N. Kaczmarek's call for the implementation of collaborative
reflection on pedagogy in all schools. This reflection would strengthen
self-organization by "forging a coherent common practice" and would
necessarily involve "rejecting a number of time-consuming directives
from the institution" in order to "restore meaning to the profession"
(p. 49). Although sometimes resembling a form of pedagogical scientism
that probably overestimates the emancipatory potential of changing
teaching practices, the author's recommendations do not reduce the
pedagogical relationship to a cold act that a prison guard or a robot
could perform. Indeed, even if it were factually more effective to adopt
an authoritarian posture or to rush headlong into educational
technology, this should still be rejected, in the name of political
ethics (pp. 42-43).
However, the emancipatory possibilities attributed to pedagogy in the
book seem to me to stem from a misunderstanding of the role of school in
the world of capital and the state. My criticisms will be based
primarily on an article published in our pages calling for a "rethinking
of a critique of the capitalist school" (6), which I find clearly
articulates the disagreement. I do not believe that school inherently
possesses "an emancipatory potential" whose trajectory could have
"deviated" (p. 12) as a result of successive reforms. In the preamble,
N. Kaczmarek asserts that "the current school is an effective tool for
enabling the dominant class to maintain its position[...], they will not
allow it to change profoundly as long as its contribution to maintaining
social inequalities remains so decisive" (p. 13). This is true, because
"no political system whatsoever has ever generated a school system that
goes against its own interests," and it is therefore the school as such,
and not simply the current school system, that "assumes the function of
reproducing the relationship between social classes and transmitting the
ideology of the dominant class" (6). Forcing the bourgeoisie, through a
general raising of the intellectual level of the proletariat (placing
them in a position of strength), to relinquish what constitutes the core
of its domination (reproducing the class division of society in each
generation) is a logical impossibility. Such a prospect can only occur
through a revolution that extends far beyond the framework of the school
(7). It is this contradiction, stemming from a truncated analysis of the
role of the school in capitalist society, that falters in the
perspective developed by the Wage-Working Network. If the author is
probably aware of this, then it must be written: we will not make the
revolution without jointly abolishing the capital that produces the
school and the school that reproduces capital.
Moreover, some of the most marginalized members of the working class are
well aware of this when schools are burned down during the urban riots
that have been shaking France in waves, or during the current student
movement. The reluctance of a significant number of students to submit
to school rules constitutes, in some respects, a critique of the
capitalist school system in action. The framework of this book,
preferring to highlight what can be salvaged in the current school
system (and which, I believe, every revolutionary employed by the
Ministry tries to do), overlooks these forms of opposition to the school
as a tool of capital and the state.
During the high school student movement at the start of the 2026
academic year (Photo by Ignazio)
It is not simply a matter of developing a critical stance towards the
institution within classrooms, but of fostering, throughout society, the
strengthening of the autonomous appropriation of knowledge. School has
not been, and is not, the only place where this acquisition is possible.
Placing in the school, through its workers, the hope of being "a weapon
for emancipation," by raising the general level of education as a
prerequisite for "seizing scientific, technical, economic, and social
debates[in order to]resist, challenge, the monopoly of the scientific
analysis of reality that the dominant classes claim to hold" (8) recalls
the old avant-garde refrain that the masses must be educated in order to
fight, that they could not, on their own, nor organize themselves
outside (or against) any hierarchical structure, but that it would be
necessary to instill in them from the outside the consciousness they
lack. While I share the author's view that we must fight tooth and nail
to defend emancipatory knowledge within the school system against the
State and against capital, I believe that the objectives of this
struggle will only be achieved through a relentless battle encompassing
actors beyond teachers and dimensions of life beyond the 13 years of
compulsory schooling. This battle would also shatter the separation
between teacher and learner and the constraints that capital
consistently imposes on the State in terms of academic standards,
diplomas, and career guidance. "If there is a need to rethink an
educational project for the proletariat, it will be one of transcending
the school as an infantilizing institution, separate from production and
society in general." It is at this level that pedagogy must be
repositioned: "when it was aligned with the revolutionary workers'
movement, then it acquired its meaning" (6). With the latter now gone,
everything remains to be done!
Habba Lekol, August 2026
Notes
(1) Which I consider non-dialectical in the sense that the social object
"school" is not sufficiently considered as an essential functioning
element of capitalist society, that is to say, in its relations with the
other elements of this society, as a dynamic totality to be abolished in
its entirety
(2) See, among others: The Work of the School: Contribution to a
Proletarian Critique of Education, Philippe Geneste, Acratie. The GRDS's
positions on the question are defended in The Common School, La Dispute.
(3) For a critical presentation, see "The 'already-there communist' of
the Wage-Working Network" in Courant Alternatif 349, April 2025 , and
for a critique, see "Should Bernard Friot (and his socialized salary) be
fried?", on tantquil.net, a somewhat dated article that nevertheless
raises some essential arguments against Friot's theses.
(4) Understanding the social and educational factors behind the RN vote,
interview with Patrick Lehingue and Bernard Pudal on the Café
Pédagogique website, May 11, 2026, about their book From the FN to the
RN: the reasons for a success, PUF, 2026
(5) As the objective of this article is not a pedagogical discussion,
the practices presented by the author, although very rich and
stimulating, will be selected from among them and presented briefly, the
core of the debate lying elsewhere.
(6) Rethinking a radical critique of the capitalist school in Courant
Alternatif 292, Summer 2019
(7) Similarly, the Trotskyist demand for a ban on layoffs has no chance
of succeeding politically, since it amounts to asking capitalists,
through legitimate means, to relinquish ownership of their means of
production
(8) The reform of vocational high schools and the prospect of a single
high school, Alain Beitone, 2019, on the GRDS website
(democratisation-scolaire.fr)
https://www.oclibertaire.lautre.net/spip.php?article4777
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
- Prev by Date:
(en) Italy, FAI, Umanita Nova #27-26 - Agoraphobia-when the public square becomes frightening. Electoral woes and rising abstentionism (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
- Next by Date:
(en) Spaine, Regeneracion: Barcelona is powerful. 1833-1843: from riots to the Jamancia and the birth of organized labor By Embat (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
A-Infos Information Center