|
A - I n f o s
|
|
a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists
**
News in all languages
Last 40 posts (Homepage)
Last two
weeks' posts
Our
archives of old posts
The last 100 posts, according
to language
Greek_
中文 Chinese_
Castellano_
Catalan_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
_The.Supplement
The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours |
of past 30 days |
of 2002 |
of 2003 |
of 2004 |
of 2005 |
of 2006 |
of 2007 |
of 2008 |
of 2009 |
of 2010 |
of 2011 |
of 2012 |
of 2013 |
of 2014 |
of 2015 |
of 2016 |
of 2017 |
of 2018 |
of 2019 |
of 2020 |
of 2021 |
of 2022 |
of 2023 |
of 2024 |
of 2025 |
of 2026
Syndication Of A-Infos - including
RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups
(en) Italy, FDCA, Cantiere #47 - The Class Dimension of Climate Change - Nicola Pedrinazzi (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
Date
Sat, 14 Nov 2026 07:53:53 +0200
Climate change is often portrayed as a problem that affects everyone.
Higher temperatures, droughts, floods, extreme weather events: faced
with these phenomena, it would seem we're all in the same boat. But
that's not the case. Climate change, like almost every other social
phenomenon, has a distinct class dimension. Not everyone contributes
equally to emissions, not everyone has the same opportunities to protect
themselves from the effects of global warming, and, above all, not
everyone decides how land is used and for what interests the economy is
organized. A family living in a poorly insulated apartment, unable to
afford to replace a boiler or install efficient systems, does not have
the same climate responsibility as a large, energy-intensive company. A
worker who must use a car to reach a distant workplace does not have the
same choices as a company owner who decides its location and work schedules.
Speaking generically about "individual behavior" therefore risks hiding
the fundamental problem: who owns, who decides, and who pays?
The transformation of our towns and cities is no accident. Every new
warehouse, every shopping center, every parking lot, every road, and
every new development arises within economic relationships and political
decisions. Land can be considered a common good or a resource to be
transformed into income and profit.
When agricultural land becomes buildable, its value can increase
dramatically. When an area is urbanized, someone cashes in on the value
generated by the transformation, while the costs are often distributed
throughout the community: more traffic, more pollution, more land use,
greater need for infrastructure, increased soil sealing, increased
pressure on sewer systems, and greater vulnerability to extreme events.
Land, however, is not infinite. Every sealed square meter is a square
meter that no longer absorbs water. Every green space eliminated means
less heat-mitigating capacity. Every new development often means more
cars, more infrastructure, and more energy consumption. This is why the
fight against climate change cannot be separated from a critique of the
commodification of land .
When a heat wave hits, the problem isn't the same for everyone. Those
who live in efficient homes, have access to green spaces, can use air
conditioning (which, it should be remembered, produces heat and consumes
energy), and perhaps can afford not to work during the hottest hours of
the day, have protective equipment that others don't. Think instead of
those who work on construction sites, in fields, in warehouses, on the
roads, or in manufacturing plants. Think of the elderly who live alone,
those who live in small, overheated apartments, and those who can't
afford energy efficiency upgrades. The same temperature therefore has
different social consequences. The same is true for extreme events. When
a flood damages a home, not everyone has the same resources to cover the
costs of reconstruction. Those with assets, savings, and insurance have
options that those already living at the limit of their income don't.
The climate crisis thus tends to exacerbate inequalities that already
exist .
Faced with this crisis, we're often offered a list of individual
behaviors: consume less, use the car less, buy "sustainable" products,
change light bulbs, recycle. Many of these practices can be helpful. But
turning the climate issue into a sum of individual responsibilities
ignores the workings of the market economy.
A worker can decide to commute by bike only if safe infrastructure
exists and the distance allows (moreover, it is often poor workers,
usually immigrants, who are the cyclists encountered every day on the
extra-urban roads connecting towns and suburbs to companies and
logistics hubs). They can reduce energy consumption only within the
limits imposed by the building they live in and their income. They can
choose an efficient home only if the real estate market makes it affordable.
People cannot be asked to "choose differently" when the material
conditions of their choices are determined by economic and social
relations over which they have no control .
The ecological transition cannot therefore be built on blaming those who
have less, even simply because, overall, those with limited economic
resources consume vastly less and therefore have a smaller environmental
impact.
Some data:
- the 10% of the world's population with the highest consumption levels
causes environmental damage worth up to $5.7 trillion a year, according
to a new study conducted by researchers from the Oxford Martin School,
the University of Oxford and the University of Leiden and published in
Communications Sustainability;
- according to the IPCC, (1) the ten percent of households with the
highest emissions produce between 34 and 45 percent of global
consumption-related emissions; the poorest half of humanity produces
between 13 and 15 percent. The gap grows even further at the extremes:
the footprint of the top one percent has been estimated to be 175 times
that of the bottom ten percent (IPCC, AR6 WGIII);
- A study published in Nature Sustainability estimates that in 2019, the
richest ten percent were responsible for 48 percent of emissions, while
the poorest half accounted for 12 percent. For the top one percent, a
significant portion comes from investments and capital ownership (Nature
Sustainability);
The climate crisis, therefore, has a reverse accounting system. Those
with the least impact often have dilapidated homes, poorer health and
well-being, and jobs that prevent them from avoiding exposure to risk.
Those with the greatest impact can purchase insulation, cooling, leisure
time, and afford a vacation or a second or third home by the sea and/or
in the mountains. However, these behaviors are then blamed for their
less than virtuous behavior, forgetting that having the ability to
choose is, first and foremost, an economic privilege.
The situation is paradoxical. On one side is the wealthy owner of luxury
properties: he travels constantly by plane-often private-disguising his
vacations as "business trips," and he owns a photovoltaic panel company.
On the other is his worker, forced to drive a ten-year-old used car and
live in a dilapidated apartment, without the financial means to insulate
the house or install renewable energy systems. The paradox is fulfilled
when the billionaire accuses the worker of being environmentally
insensitive, praising himself as a champion of ethics simply because he
sells solar panels. What a shining example of morality!
It is precisely at the local level that these contradictions become
concrete.
A municipal administration should use urban planning tools to decide
where to build, where not to build, how much land to consume, which
areas to reclaim, and where to build parks, parking lots, bike paths,
and infrastructure.
It can encourage the concreting or the regeneration of existing buildings.
It can design completely waterproof squares or transform them into
green, tree-lined and permeable spaces.
It can spend public resources to make schools and municipal buildings
energy efficient or let families individually bear the costs of the
transition.
It can promote private mobility or build real alternatives to the
automobile.
These aren't simply technical issues. They are political choices , and
the market, profit, and various power dynamics play a significant role
in these choices, and technology is often a powerful tool that benefits
capital rather than the people.
There is a real risk: using the climate crisis to further shift the
costs of the transition onto the working classes.
Mandatory energy efficiency improvements, without funding reform, create
profound social injustice. Current incentives reward high incomes and
exclude the poorest. Thus, those who own a home solely for living are
forced to sustain disproportionate and unsustainable costs.
If energy costs rise without ensuring adequate wages and efficient
public services, the burden of the transition falls on the lowest incomes.
If traffic restrictions are introduced without offering accessible and
widespread public transport, the result isn't fairer mobility: it's
simply a new penalty for those who can't afford alternatives. A true
ecological transition must therefore also be a social "transition . "
It should not ask for equal sacrifices from people who live in
profoundly different conditions.
The fundamental question then becomes that of moving from the
authoritarian control of the territory and resources for the benefit of
capital to the collective care of the territory, where everyone is an
inseparable part of it and of equal value.
It's legitimate to ask why decisions with a profound social impact must
be primarily driven by financial returns. This model pushes the
development of areas that communities would prefer to preserve as
public, green, or agricultural spaces, sacrificing collective well-being
for profit. Similarly, energy efficiency upgrades are left to the
economic capacity of individuals, rather than being addressed for what
they truly are: a structural and community investment that can no longer
be postponed.
The answer cannot simply be "more efficient administration," because
efficiency and development are not always synonymous with progress; in
fact, the results seem to demonstrate the opposite.
We need to question who decides on the use of resources and land .
This means protecting public assets, removing as much land as possible
from speculation, encouraging the redevelopment of existing structures,
preventing indiscriminate land consumption, and transforming urban
spaces into assets truly accessible to the entire community.
Let's consider seemingly simple interventions. Plant trees along streets
and in parking lots. Reclaim abandoned areas. Create urban parks and
forests. Make asphalt surfaces permeable. Build rainwater retention
systems. Upgrade schools for energy efficiency. Install photovoltaic
panels on public buildings. Create energy communities that are truly
focused on reducing energy poverty, not just as a pretext for profit and
speculation at the community's expense. A city where the shade of trees
is a public good, where rainwater is not just considered a problem to be
quickly discharged into the sewers, where energy produced by public
plants can be used to reduce utility costs and support those who have less.
From this perspective, the "ecological transition" must also be about
the redistribution of wealth and not about marketing for financial
investments and the centralization of power.
We need a different vision of the city and social organization, with the
understanding that relying solely on "technology" is not a good
solution, especially if we remain within a capitalist and market system.
The fight against the exploitation of the land is inextricably linked to
the fight against the exploitation of man by man, with the prospect of
replacing the logic of profit and the market with care. On this point,
some populations we Westerners call backward have something to teach us,
without wanting to fall into primitivism or tribalism.
Then there is another dimension that must not be forgotten: work.
The climate crisis is making it increasingly difficult to work in
extreme heat, and the associated and related risks are increasing. But
the solution can't be just technological.
Workers' health and bargaining power must be prioritized: adequate
breaks, reduced heat exposure, reduced working hours without a reduction
in pay, and the right to stop work when conditions become dangerous.
Productivity must be for life.
In this sense, the climate issue is directly connected to the history of
class struggle: those who control their own time, their own work, and
the conditions in which they work possess part of the power needed to
address crises, including the ecological crisis.
The climate crisis won't be solved by planting a few trees or with a
sustainability ad campaign. But even denouncing capitalism isn't enough
if it doesn't translate into concrete conflict and organization.
In the local communities, this means building committees against land
use, defending green spaces, organizing against pollution, demanding
efficient public transportation, demanding energy-efficient public
buildings, opposing the privatization of services, and asserting the
collective right to decide how the land is transformed.
It means connecting environmental struggles to those for wages, housing,
public services, and health.
Because the worker who fights against factory pollution, the resident
who opposes the concreting of the neighborhood and those who demand the
right to a decent home are not fighting three different battles .
They are questioning the very social model.
Capitalism has a fundamental characteristic: it tends to transform every
need into an opportunity for profit. Even the climate crisis has become
a market: new infrastructure, new "green" products, new forms of debt,
new speculative opportunities.
The question we must ask ourselves is instead another: transition for
whom? Decided by whom?
If the answer is that workers and the working classes will once again
pay the price, then we are not facing an ecological transition, but a
reorganization of the economic system under new conditions.
A truly radical climate policy must instead start from collective needs:
housing, health, water, energy, mobility, food, green spaces, safe work.
Land is not a commodity. Energy is not a luxury. Water is not property.
Air does not belong to those who can afford to pollute it. The ability
to live in a healthy environment cannot depend on income.
The fight against climate change will also be a fight against
inequality, or a new form of inequality. This is why environmental
protection must meet class struggle. Not to add a new demand to the many
already existing, but because the ecological crisis forces us to ask a
fundamental question: who decides how we live, what we produce, what we
consume, and how we co-inhabit the land we inhabit?
The answer, from below, can only be one: not the market, not rent, not
profit.
The community. The workers. The residents. All those who live and travel
through that territory every day. And, above all, their ability to
organize and collectively reclaim the power to decide.
Note
1) The IPCC ( Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change ) is the main
international body for the scientific assessment of climate change .
https://alternativalibertaria.org/
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
A-Infos Information Center