|
A - I n f o s
|
|
a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists
**
News in all languages
Last 40 posts (Homepage)
Last two
weeks' posts
Our
archives of old posts
The last 100 posts, according
to language
Greek_
中文 Chinese_
Castellano_
Catalan_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
_The.Supplement
The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours |
of past 30 days |
of 2002 |
of 2003 |
of 2004 |
of 2005 |
of 2006 |
of 2007 |
of 2008 |
of 2009 |
of 2010 |
of 2011 |
of 2012 |
of 2013 |
of 2014 |
of 2015 |
of 2016 |
of 2017 |
of 2018 |
of 2019 |
of 2020 |
of 2021 |
of 2022 |
of 2023 |
of 2024 |
of 2025 |
of 2026
Syndication Of A-Infos - including
RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups
(en) France, OCL CA #363 - EDUCATION FILES - EVARS: What can schools do in the face of patriarchy? - (2/2) - EVARS: Possibilities and Contradictions (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
Date
Thu, 12 Nov 2026 08:57:08 +0200
As an education worker, I believe it is important to adopt egalitarian
teaching practices and incorporate feminist teaching content, including
in extracurricular initiatives. However, the (relatively uncritical)
enthusiasm of a large part of the feminist movement for sex,
relationship, and emotional education in schools (SREWS) seems to
overlook some of its contradictions. In the first part of this work , I
sought to demonstrate that the capitalist school system has historically
not been neutral ground for feminism. Here, I will attempt to detail the
possibilities and limitations of SREWS in light of a critique of the
capitalist school system and my experience implementing SREWS in a
middle school setting.
"Information dedicated to equality between men and women, the fight
against sexist prejudices, and the fight against violence against women
and domestic violence is provided at all stages of schooling.
Schools[...]may partner for this purpose with women's rights
organizations that promote equality between men and women, and with
personnel involved in the prevention and prosecution of such violence."
This excerpt from the education code clearly illustrates the mission the
State assigns to schools regarding gender equality: it is addressed
through education, which can be provided by school staff, external
organizations, or even... the police (which, thankfully, isn't all that
common).
So, what is actually being implemented in schools, and what role do
revolutionaries play in these initiatives? How can we explain this "holy
alliance" between feminism and the State around schools?
In the feminist demonstration of November 23, 2024
Sexuality and gender equality education: where do we stand?
Among the 16,000 staff members trained since February 2025, according to
the Ministry, to become gender equality experts (the vast majority of
whom are women) and to teach courses on gender equality, many have a
feminist perspective. In the Versailles academy, the largest in France,
112 middle and high schools (out of 812) have already received a
"girls-boys equality label" since its launch in 2023, and the number is
increasing rapidly. While this label ultimately carries little weight
(it is also a way for career-driven school principals to promote their
own interests), its growth, along with the increasing institutional and
activist literature on the subject, demonstrates a certain enthusiasm,
which was further solidified by the promulgation of the official gender
equality curriculum in 2025. This curriculum establishes a framework for
the knowledge to be taught from preschool through high school, just like
any other subject, and provides a common reference point for teachers,
school nurses, associations, and others.
Some excerpts (1). In kindergarten, for example, children will be taught
to "know their bodies; understand what intimacy is; identify a trusted
person." In 6th grade, they will be taught to "understand and learn to
live with the changes in their bodies," in 5th grade to "distinguish
between public and private life, reflecting on what individual freedom
means, particularly on social media," in 4th grade to "approach
sexuality as a complex reality that can involve pleasure, love,
reproduction, etc.", and in 11th grade to "desire and want, give or
refuse consent, know how to be free and respect others and their own
freedoms; be oneself, between acceptance and denial." Specific
variations of these objectives, which sometimes blur the lines between
responsible citizenship, self-realization in a liberal sense, and
crucial teachings about sexuality, are detailed in the curriculum.
Whatever one might say, the EVARS curriculum is far more comprehensive
and feminist than anything that was possible in the past (2).
So, locally, staff from the Ministry of Education are setting up
classroom sessions, out-of-class interventions on days like March 8th,
sometimes supported by student ambassadors, involving associations,
conducting local assessments... In agreement with Simon Massei, a
sociologist who has carried out field studies on the subject (3), I
think this is beneficial, particularly for young girls "through the
sharing of experiences or the acquisition of crucial information about
sexuality, especially in the context of single-sex discussions[where
they can]freely discuss their problems, address situations of harassment
or[...]reveal having been victims of sexual assault," obtaining
"technical details about the female genitalia," which has "political
effects by providing students with scientific arguments to counter
conservative or religious discourse." My experience aligns with Massei's
observations, and I would add that students discovering an attraction to
the same sex can be reassured by a non-stigmatizing and protective
discourse.
But female students from working-class backgrounds don't fully embrace
the discourse presented during these sessions: only in a "selective"
way, often rejecting, for example, anything that challenges "an ideal of
fidelity or virginity before marriage," either out of personal
convictions or to maintain a sense of "respectability." They also
associate feminism with a form of passivity and complaining, far removed
from the feminine pride they display daily. In this same environment,
many boys, while still listening with interest to what they believe will
be useful later, sometimes deliberately adopt a strategy of "buffoonery"
to "resist the symbolic violence of the institution" that manifests
itself at school and in these sessions in particular, by questioning
certain values. There would therefore be good and bad students of
equality, since equality becomes, within the school setting, "one lesson
among others, and students' ability to learn and recite it without error
depends less on their personal convictions on the subject than on their
family socialization and their ranking in the school system."
However, the relatively rapid implementation of the EVARS program masks
the gaps: few schools have a truly coordinated policy, and "currently,
no budget is allocated for these sessions (4)." Once again, schools are
expected to solve society's problems based on a directive from above,
without much prior planning.
Lone activists on the front lines
The academic delegate for gender equality (and inspector!) in the
Versailles academy, addressing the gender equality coordinators, told
them in an email in 2026: "Your commitment is essential: every day, in
schools and institutions, you work to prevent violence, support
students, change perceptions, and build a more peaceful, respectful, and
inclusive school climate for everyone." Without, of course, denigrating
the stated objectives, this message nevertheless raises a significant
paradox: the blurring of lines between institutional and activist
discourse. Within the Ministry, at its various levels, this mix is
found, combining the promotion of inclusive writing and "academic
roadmaps," adherence to all the current activist codes (pronouns,
trigger warnings (5)...), and top-down control by the rector. Yet,
despite this blurring, on the ground, the discussions held during gender
equality sessions are far from being universally feminist. The adoption
of activist codes has only occurred at the top of the hierarchy, while
conservative discourse continues to be widespread at the bottom.
However, resources sometimes emanating directly from feminist
collectives are relayed into classrooms, and some of the organizations
involved may deliver a highly political feminist discourse, without
necessarily adapting it to the students in front of them. This is not
without friction, because, as one teacher leading EVARS sessions
reports, in the eyes of students and colleagues, "the teacher who works
on these issues can be perceived not as a professional, but as a
political adversary. And yet, the institution acts as if this work could
be done without conflict. It imposes a curriculum, but leaves
professionals on the front line, without sufficient training, without
dedicated time, without identified human resources, without clear
protection. (6)"
An example of resources provided to the designated contacts
The paradoxes of outsourcing
Implementing internally the three mandatory sessions stipulated by the
2001 law, an obligation the State fails to fulfill every year in a
context of ongoing austerity, is virtually impossible. Therefore,
"decentralization and the State's disengagement have led associations,
if not to replace the State, at least to become both an instrument of
public action and a variable for adjustment. (3)" Following in the
footsteps of historical feminist associations like the Family Planning
Association, which has long been active in schools but maintains its
political independence, "the market for gender equality education
developed in the 2000s," characterized by the precarious contracts
typical of the non-profit sector, its close dependence on local
authorities, and sometimes, its institutional feminist discourse
mirroring that of the government. The scarcity of funding also exposes
EVARS to a form of privatization by startups or large platforms offering
online courses (much cheaper than those offered by feminist
associations), and to the reactionary crusade of capitalists like
Pierre-Édouard Stérin, who "already supports numerous conservative
associations specializing in EVARS (7)."
However, for a number of teachers and administrators, outsourcing to
associations is not a risk or a pitfall. On the contrary, it becomes a
solution to compensate for the reluctance to address sensitive issues
with students, particularly after the assassinations of Samuel Paty and
Dominique Bernard. It also allows them to avoid defining an ambitious
policy, simply by having the required teaching hours delivered by
associations. Properly addressing the prevention of violence against
children within the national education system, for example, would mean
having to manage a multitude of sexual violence cases (affecting 160,000
child victims each year according to CIIVISE (8)) for which nothing is
in place: untrained education professionals, and ridiculously inadequate
support, placement, and justice systems. The classic "don't rock the
boat" approach therefore prevails.
It would be wrong to believe that schools have suddenly become feminist
thanks to the implementation of the EVARS (Educational and Social Action
Program). Whereas even minimally combating patriarchy in schools would
require genuine internal reflection on the curriculum, but also on daily
teaching practices and on the detection and support of student victims
(and perpetrators), we are instead sprinkling a few hours here and there.
Some contradictions of EVARS
Repressive Logic
: EVARS does not break free from the dominant framework for addressing
gender-based and sexual violence (GBV) in society, which relies on
repression. Thus, for students, even if restorative justice initiatives
can be organized locally and on an ad hoc basis, and a ministerial guide
exists to promote them (9), the logic remains one of punishment and
exclusion. Similarly, for its staff, "the ministry wishes to be able to
rely on an information system dedicated to background checks in order to
simplify the procedure and to be able to carry it out at a frequency of
three to five years. (10)"
Hypocrisy of the Ministry.
Coming from a capitalist and patriarchal institution (see previous
article), one can always doubt the real possibilities of what it
proposes in terms of feminism. Isn't this the same institution that
abandoned and then acknowledged its failings in the case of the suicide,
on September 1, 2025, of Caroline Grandjean, a school principal in a
village in the Cantal region, after two years of homophobic harassment
by parents of students (11)? Where are the words denouncing this
institutional mistreatment (among others) of the activist inspectors who
relay feminist discourse within the ministry?
Another hypocrisy is the promotion, even in the most segregated middle
schools, of initiatives to promote engineering as a career to female
students, while the social sorting that prevails there will steer both
girls AND boys towards short courses, vocational training,
apprenticeships... State-sponsored bourgeois feminism sometimes serves
to mask the harsh reality of class. Moreover, the school is only able to
question its own role in male domination from the point of view of
gendered orientation and the lower level of girls in math, but never for
all the gestures and spaces which reproduce patriarchy every day (see
previous article).
Gathering in memory of Caroline Grandjean
Lack of autonomy from the State.
For the Lutte de classes éducation union, a splinter group of SUD, the
unions supposedly representing the opposition (FSU, CGT, SUD), in
welcoming the promulgation of the EVARS program, are deluding themselves
that "the ills of society[can]be combated by changes in school curricula
and new 'pedagogies'[...]without touching the overall socio-economic
structure." Moreover, as with most reforms, it believes that there will
be a significant dilution between the program and reality, and that
ultimately, "teachers will therefore have to show initiative, and in the
vast majority of cases, this will mean doing something completely
different from what is expected." (12)
The generally uncritical alliance of feminism, the left, and the unions
around EVARS is indeed cause for concern. For Elsa Deck Marsault,
recalling the debates of the 1970s, "the idea of considering the law,
police stations, and the State as emancipatory spaces was not always a
given within the feminist movement.[...]However, the mistrust of most
feminists toward institutional channels gradually weakened, and the end
of the 1970s saw the formalization of an alliance between feminists and
the State on the definition of a 'security problem' and on solutions to
address it. (13)" Simon Massei concurs: "The State was not the target at
that time" because "the MLF, welcoming many former activists from
far-left organizations, initially adopted a revolutionary stance. (3)"
The gradual institutionalization of feminism would lead to a decline in
autonomous initiatives in the areas of self-education and abortion.
Moreover, intervening in the school environment implies accepting
certain consequences: the rejection of the EVARS baby with the school
bathwater by students who are very rightly at odds with the school.
An Individual-Centered Vision:
In schools, the first measures taken by the State Secretariat for
Women's Affairs regarding textbooks (1976), followed by Mitterrand's
rise to power in 1981, marked a turning point "for some MLF activists
who then converted to socialist reformism, some even joining the cabinet
of the new Minister for Women's Rights (3)." While the feminist movement
became partially integrated into the state, "at that time, schools were
only one arena among others in the fight against sexism" (media,
advertising, etc.). It was the shift from fighting sexism as a system of
domination to "an approach based on stereotypes" in the 1990s,
accompanying the "psychologization of the problem," that established an
individualizing vision based on "raising awareness among young people
before they make their career choices," a vision compatible with the
school setting. Rather than fighting against forced career choices or
the production of gendered visions in advertising, we encourage girls to
take an interest in other fields themselves and we teach young people to
"deconstruct stereotypes".
Feminist collage during the Mazan rape trial demanding maximum sentences
for the accused
Citizenship, secularism and living together: the new moral order in schools
While social and cultural education (SCE) can provide students with
tools to understand power structures, it remains within a republican and
liberal framework, centered on the individual's obligation to respect
societal rules. In this sense, it falls under the umbrella of various
forms of "education about" (health, citizenship, etc.). SCE is indeed
often addressed, in the name of prevention, in connection with the
dangers of alcohol, tobacco, or the internet. It was from 2005 onward
that citizenship education emerged as the state's preferred solution.
The state expects schools to "fulfill a regulatory and adaptive
function, so that they can (re)weave a failing social fabric and
(re)form a cohesion shattered by the dynamics of capitalism." It is the
school staff who are assigned the role of firefighters to carry out this
obviously (and thankfully) impossible task of training docile and
compliant citizens, that is to say, citizens who respect and adhere to a
set of rules enabling 'living together'. (14)
Building 'living together' in an institution 'imbued with the values of
the capitalist system it serves: competition, rivalry, consumption,
accumulation, individualism' is achieved by developing 'soft skills',
which effectively become a competency that can be assessed by the
institution, targeted at certain neighborhoods. Based on a geographical
study of EVARS's interventions in schools, Simon Massei puts forward the
thesis of a "racialization of anti-sexism" in schools, the targeting of
which by policies, through the territorialization of social and
educational policies (priority education, urban policy, delinquency
prevention) and the autonomy of schools, "obeys a socio-economic logic
as much as a racial logic." The "education for" programs obviously aim
to instill republican and authoritarian civic-mindedness in the children
of working-class families, and, although the adjective "racial" could
aptly be replaced here by "racist," the joint development of anti-sexism
in schools and the focus on the "Muslim problem" by politicians suggests
that institutional actors make an implicit racist link between
immigration and sexism. Moreover, it is important to highlight the
"embedding of anti-sexist discourse[...]within a 'secular' rhetoric" in
its discriminatory form towards the descendants of North African immigrants.
Conversely, in affluent schools, EVARS interventions frequently take the
form of testimonials from female executives in the private sector,
intended to encourage high-achieving students not to give up. Yet, the
problems of gender-based violence (GBV) are generally the same there as
in working-class schools. But in wealthy schools, the institution
prefers to see it as an individual failing linked to an overly
testosterone-driven male puberty rather than a socially entrenched
problem specific to the "dangerous classes."
Conclusion: Feminism in a strange state
Investing locally in radical feminist education (RFE) is an
understandable choice that opens up interesting possibilities for
students, quite similar to the classic joys and sorrows of traditional
education. For this education to be as effective as possible, it is
important to build it as a team, to know the students, to adapt the
content to their needs, and to anticipate obstacles.
And these are numerous, because everything in the school system
logically opposes the implementation of a radical feminist education in
place of the intense conditioning to the norms of capital, the State,
and patriarchy that takes place there during the 13 years of compulsory
schooling. The contradictions of RFE are ultimately the same as those of
contemporary dominant feminism (15): punitive logic, dependence on the
State, absence of a class perspective, individualism of
'deconstruction'. Relying on the school (as one relies on the justice
system to resolve gender-based violence) reflects the contemporary
inability to develop an autonomous revolutionary perspective.
zyg, September 2026
Notes
(1) For details of classroom sessions based on the testimony of a
"facilitator of sex and relationship education in middle schools, high
schools, and vocational training programs for 20 years," see the very
interesting *Pugère la vie. À l'école des genres* by Dr. Kpote (2023).
(2) Compare the content of the sex education detailed in the previous
article with the current EVARS program available on the eduscol website...
(3) Simon Massei, *Disciplining the Suburbs?* Gender equality education
gone astray, La Dispute, 2024.
(4) Sexuality (education about), Casse-Rôles no. 35, February-April
2026. Interesting articles on EVARS are available in this special issue
of the feminist and libertarian journal.
(5) Expression referring to the act of warning someone before exposing
them to content deemed violent, offensive, oppressive...
(6) Alone on the front line: EVARS and the impossible neutrality of
schools, Marie-Simon, Le club de Médiapart, May 4, 2026.
(7) "We've been taken for a ride by the private sector": associations
fear the privatization of EVARS, Basta!, January 7, 2026.
(8) Independent Commission on Incest and Sexual Violence Against
Children, 2023 figures.
(9) For example: Restorative circles at the Cooperative College and
Polytechnique d'Aubervilliers: Repair rather than punish, April 2026,
available on questionsdeclasses.org, and Guide for preventive and
restorative justice in schools published by the Ministry in 2014
(10) Protocol for action in the event of sexist or sexual violence
within schools and educational establishments, March 2026
(11) See the various union press releases on the SUD Education website.
(12) Press release EVARS Program: a "union victory" in 2025 from Lutte
de classes éducation Aquitaine available on-luttedeclasses.fr. This
press release launches a scathing attack on other education unions,
without ever mentioning the need for sex education as such, as if the
object of the criticism were of no importance...
(13) "Rape is rape." "Twenty years for each": how feminism became
trapped in a punitive and carceral ideal, Elsa Deck Marsault, March 7,
2026, on slate.fr
(14) Education, a means of integration or emancipation?, Courant
Alternatif Special Issue on schools, 2011
(15) The Mazan rape trial, the men, and the feminist strategy, Courant
Alternatif 347, February 2025
https://www.oclibertaire.lautre.net/spip.php?article4780
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
- Prev by Date:
(en) Brazil, OSL: Our stance regarding the electoral landscape and the need for organization in the class struggle. (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
- Next by Date:
(en) Italy, FDCA, Cantiere #47 - Surrogacy: Between Biowork, the Market, and Family Diversity. - Stefania Baschieri (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
A-Infos Information Center