|
A - I n f o s
|
|
a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists
**
News in all languages
Last 40 posts (Homepage)
Last two
weeks' posts
Our
archives of old posts
The last 100 posts, according
to language
Greek_
中文 Chinese_
Castellano_
Catalan_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
_The.Supplement
The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours |
of past 30 days |
of 2002 |
of 2003 |
of 2004 |
of 2005 |
of 2006 |
of 2007 |
of 2008 |
of 2009 |
of 2010 |
of 2011 |
of 2012 |
of 2013 |
of 2014 |
of 2015 |
of 2016 |
of 2017 |
of 2018 |
of 2019 |
of 2020 |
of 2021 |
of 2022 |
of 2023 |
of 2024 |
of 2025 |
of 2026
Syndication Of A-Infos - including
RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups
(en) France, OCL CA #363 - EDUCATION FILES - EVARS: Faced with patriarchy, what can schools do? (1/2) - The history of schooling, between capital and patriarchy (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
Date
Wed, 11 Nov 2026 09:48:30 +0200
Like the army, the prison, industry, or other public services (1), the
school constitutes an element of a society governed by the pursuit of
profit (capitalism) and ensuring male domination (patriarchy). Rife with
the social contradictions of these two systems, it contributes to
reproducing them, but, as a battleground, it can also be a site of
resistance. Before examining the possibilities and limitations of
education in affective, relational, and sexual life (EVARS) , it is
important to delve into the history of the school system in order to
understand the terrain on which the feminist struggle takes place within
schools.
From the highest levels of the Ministry of National Education to
feminist demonstrations teeming with slogans advocating for "boys'
education" or "sex education" in schools, and including the so-called
"struggle" or "social transformation" unions (FSU, CGT, SUD), there
seems to be a consensus today that schools, and therefore the State,
play a central role in the feminist struggle. While the question of
girls' education (or lack thereof), its content compared to that of
boys, and sex education-in short, gender relations in schools-has always
been a topic of public debate, the form these relations have taken in
schools must be understood as resulting from a complex interplay between
the objectives of maintaining the dominance of capital and patriarchy,
the constraints of social and demographic changes, and the power
dynamics among a large number of actors. Ultimately, the emancipation of
women (and the proletariat) rarely materialized.
Mixed or single-sex spaces: the sexual division of labor and the
necessities of capital
Before industrialization, educational institutions were mostly strictly
male, "simply because girls were not educated,[...]they learned the
skills their mothers had already passed down at home. From the 16th
century onward, they entered the 'little schools' run by nuns. There,
they could learn to read, rarely to write.[...]This single-sex education
was initially the result of a deliberate and decreed segregation of the
sexes by the Church (2)."
Then, from 1833 (Guizot Law), primary public education was initially
reserved for boys, thus confining girls' education to the domestic
sphere. In 1850, the Falloux Law opened it up to girls. In 1880, the
Camille Sée Law opened the doors of secondary education to women (with
different and less comprehensive curricula), but as the feminist
Hubertine Auclert pointed out, not only did this education remain
single-sex, but it was not "a means of financial gain for women," and
therefore "parents will not consider making sacrifices to educate their
daughters, but to provide them with dowries (3)." Yet, coeducation
between the sexes existed at this time, at least partially (United
States, Netherlands, Italy). Educators, divided, disagreed on the best
course of action, some believing "that coeducation encourages a form of
unbridled independence among young American girls, thus threatening
traditional gender roles."
The beginning of co-educational schools
At that time, feminists demanded equal education for women, but not all
of them did so from the same perspective. Bourgeois feminists (Georges
Sand) and revolutionary feminists (Flora Tristan, Louise Michel,
Elisabeth Dmitrieff, and André Léo) disagreed. While in the former case,
education should enable bourgeois women to be equal to bourgeois men,
the revolutionaries, on the contrary, "constantly linked, throughout the
19th century, the struggle of women and that of the workers' movement
(4)." Indeed, the role of the modern school, since its origins in the
era of industrialization, has been to be "the daughter and servant of
capitalism" (Freinet). The fiercely anticlerical (but capitalist) Third
Republic established a school system that provided a minimal education
to the children of workers and peasants in the region, standardized the
language at the expense of local dialects, and sang the praises of the
Nation in case it became necessary to send young cannon fodder to their
deaths for industrialists. These objectives were obviously reflected in
differentiated curricula for girls and boys, thus reproducing the sexual
division of labor and warfare. This system of differentiated education,
explicitly preparing women for the domestic sphere and men for the
factory, would persist for a long time, in accordance with the way in
which capital reshaped the family during industrialization (5). In
response, throughout the 19th and 20th centuries, proletarian or
anarchist education initiatives offered mixed or non-mixed spaces
(depending on the objectives) more or less outside the State, the study
of which is not the subject of this article, which is focused on the
dominant school.
During the 20th century, several changes took place. A nascent and
sporadic coeducation persisted and developed (6). High school curricula
became identical for both sexes from 1924 onward, allowing women to
prepare for the baccalaureate and providing a form of recognition of the
intellectual equality of all secondary school students (therefore,
exclusively members of the upper classes). "The gradual introduction of
coeducation in France from the 1960s onward[it became compulsory in
1975]was more the consequence of strong demographic growth, economic
imperatives, and the expansion of education than the result of genuine
reflection on how to achieve gender equality. There was therefore no
debate surrounding an educational project aimed at changing gender
relations. (2)" But, from then on, with coeducation becoming the norm,
"observations about the differences between girls and boys became the
subject of study and inquiry," such as the underrepresentation of women
in the sciences. Inequality in gender mixing thus becomes visible (and
deplored by feminists), but persists because the school is part of
capitalist and patriarchal society, both as a cause and as a consequence
of its functioning.
The school as a reflection and matrix of patriarchy
Indeed, even within a co-educational framework, from the earliest age,
daycare and then school contribute to reproducing not only class society
but also patriarchy. A 2012 report by the General Inspectorate of Social
Affairs noted, with regard to daycare centers, greater stimulation and
encouragement of boys for group activities, verbal interaction, and
physical abilities, while the "appearance[of girls]is more the object of
adult attention (7)." Then, at school, sociologist Marie Duru-Bellat
showed that teachers judge work differently, tending "to compliment
boys' work for its intelligence or originality, and girls' work for its
seriousness and neatness," and Nicole Mosconi, also a sociologist,
emphasizes that "boys' indiscipline is tolerated, seen as unfortunate
but inevitable behavior, whereas it is stigmatized and sometimes
violently rejected in girls, from whom docility is expected." And, for
teachers, girls "do all they can" academically while they imagine that
boys "can do better (8)".
Through school punishment, exclusion from classes or the school itself,
a rite of passage or a 'medal of manhood' is also at play within the
boys' group. "During adolescence, masculine identity is shaped in
relation to peer groups.[...]Displays of strength, frequent fights, and
sexist and homophobic insults constitute the daily life of many boys
(9)." These boys are caught between the school rules, which "demand
discretion, respect, work, and obedience[values identified as
'feminine']," and integration into the boys' group, which pushes them to
"break the rules, be insolent, act the fool, monopolize attention, and
use their physical strength (10)." The more academically inclined
behavior of girls is then perceived by some boys as a product of the
institution that excludes them, as is the case with the behavior of
good-achieving boys, whose devaluation can be achieved through
stereotypes associating 'intellectual' with 'faggot'. Masculinist
behaviors are thus a form of identity compensation for academic failure
for young boys, which the institution validates through punishment,
while claiming to combat them.
Furthermore, as historically denounced by feminists in the 1970s,
textbooks convey "an invisibility and inferiorization of women; a
persistence of stereotypes in the gendered division of labor,
activities, and social spaces; a homogenization of the group of women;
ordinary and banalized sexism; an absence of counter-stereotypes
(dominance by women and feminism are rarely addressed) (2)."
At the national (and European) level, the DEPP (11) highlights a
persistent gap between performance in French (where girls outperform
boys) and mathematics (where boys outperform boys), whether at the
beginning of sixth grade or in tenth grade. Furthermore, "in France,
girls are more likely to choose general and technological tracks than
boys, who are more numerous in vocational tracks, particularly
apprenticeships," resulting, in effect, in the (almost) single-sex
operation of many educational pathways.
Finally, the schoolyard sports field (often used for soccer),
predominantly occupied by boys, forces girls who wish to cross it to
take detours, not to mention the toilets, changing rooms, hallways, and
cafeteria. In other words, this reflects the relegation of women to
peripheral spaces to the detriment of men, who remain central and
legitimate in the public sphere.
The playground as drawn by a student (G for spaces occupied by boys, F
for girls)
If we add to this the gender stereotypes conveyed by social networks,
which are widely consumed by younger people, as well as the overall lack
of training for education workers on these issues, nothing currently
allows us to really change the trend at the institutional level, which
functions like a machine for reproducing gender relations.
Educating about sexuality and gender equality in schools?
At the beginning of the 20th century, school curricula were purged of
all references to sexuality in order to preserve "childlike innocence,"
as knowledge was believed to inevitably lead to vice (especially for
women, who were expected to remain ignorant until their wedding night).
Neo-Malthusians, feminists (such as Nelly Roussel), and doctors,
however, unsuccessfully petitioned the state for sex education in
schools. This last group founded the French Society for Sanitary and
Moral Prophylaxis to prevent the spread of venereal diseases. Doctors
then gave talks to girls from working-class backgrounds and (rarely)
lectures exclusively for male high school students, outside of school
hours, with the approval of the principals least concerned by the
potential scandal. High school girls will therefore not have the
opportunity to attend, for example, the lecture entitled "Venus and Her
Dangers," given by the French National League Against Venereal Disease
at the Lycée Condorcet in Paris in 1925, which asserted that "to seek
pleasure in love and not a child is to confuse the means with the end,"
urging them to "remain chaste in order to be strong," stigmatizing the
"selfish masturbator," associating the transmission of venereal diseases
solely with women, and mentioning sterility as the only female symptom
of these infections... The attempt by the Minister of National
Education, Jean Zay (in conjunction with the Minister of Health), to
introduce sex education in schools in 1937 met with opposition from the
Federation of Parents' Associations, not to mention that of Catholic
circles. The State, medicine, feminists, parents, and religious
figures-the actors in a controversy that has continued ever since-are
already identified.
A gem from 1925
"It was the economic, social, and cultural shifts of the Trente
Glorieuses (Thirty Glorious Years) that fostered the initial
institutionalization of sex education in schools.[...]Other contributing
factors included the extension of compulsory schooling[...]and the
gradual introduction of coeducation, which strengthened the support of
those who believed that schools could not ignore issues related to
sexuality. (12)" Young people's sexuality became more visible, and
attitudes evolved in favor of sex education (high school action
committees in 1968 demanded it). Gradually, it gained acceptance, but in
a very conservative society, it remained tasked with protecting against
"sexual deviations" such as homosexuality. However, in the 1960s,
Planned Parenthood sought to develop "an ethic of fulfillment and
responsibility" in sexuality and intervened in schools, also advocating
for the right to abortion. The Fontanet circular of 1973 will frame the
initiatives and arbitrate between the various pressures (unions and
parents of students are divided): it distinguishes between compulsory
"sexual information", purely scientific and biological (reproduction,
hygiene) and "education in sexual responsibility" which is optional, so
as not to go against the role of families, retaining a right of
oversight on the participation of their offspring in these sessions.
The context of the AIDS epidemic in the 1980s led to a strengthening of
sex education, which no longer focused solely on prevention but also
addressed sexuality in a "positive approach" linking "romantic
relationships, solidarity, and trust." In the 1990s, opposition from
Catholic circles was finally overcome, and the mandatory nature of sex
education was enshrined in law in 2001: "Information and education on
sexuality are provided in primary, middle, and high schools with at
least three sessions per year, in homogeneous age groups." External
speakers may deliver these sessions, but "under the responsibility and
supervision of National Education staff (nurses, student life
coordinators, teachers, etc.)." "While reactionary opposition groups may
have successfully thwarted the ABCD of Equality program during
Hollande's presidency, the institutionalization of education in
emotional, relational, and sexual life, with the promulgation of an
official curriculum in 2025, is currently a victory. However, this
victory is deceptive, as recent figures indicate that only 15 to 20% of
secondary school students benefit from these mandatory sessions, due to
insufficient resources and the fact that these initiatives rely
primarily on the motivation of local teams. The state has nonetheless
been condemned in court for this deficiency, a sign that the balance of
power has profoundly shifted."
A map of the anti-EVARS movement by the Questions de classe collective
Conclusion: From sex education in schools to comprehensive self-education
By addressing three different aspects of the link between school and
gender relations (coeducation, gendered reproduction, and sex
education), this article seeks to demonstrate that school is not a
neutral ground that could enable complete sexual emancipation through a
few well-intentioned laws and programs. While the feminist power dynamic
obviously plays a role in the adoption of certain measures, and while it
is vital that sex education be provided (for the prevention of violence
against minors, to provide reliable knowledge about the body and
sexuality, and to counterbalance the influence of families), the role of
school remains to reproduce the necessities of society, foremost among
them the class division. This division, based on the separation between
a predominantly male productive sphere (industry, construction,
agriculture, engineering) and a predominantly female reproductive sphere
(care, teaching, cleaning, domestic work), is perpetuated by the school
through ideology and guidance. Radically challenging the patriarchal
role of schools can therefore only be done on the condition of also
questioning the class society that sets the framework for it.
Within this framework, what exactly does the recent EVARS program,
clearly progressive in inspiration and largely supported by the left,
represent? Several hypotheses can be put forward. First, after a
continuous decline since the AIDS epidemic, sexually transmitted
infections have been on the rise for several years, particularly among
young people, and EVARS could constitute a state-led response. Second, a
well-known reflex in France is to ask schools to solve the problem
whenever there is a major social issue-an easy and inexpensive solution,
allowing those in power to demonstrate that they are taking action. This
is also the case with the prevention of sexist and sexual violence
(against women or minors), harassment (sexual or not),
'radicalisation'... Finally, EVARS also testifies to an ideological
evolution of liberal society, very attached to individual well-being and
'living together', in which 'affective, relational' life and sexuality
are seen as central dimensions, which can be treated with the republican
reading grid of the moment, stigmatizing for example the supposed
'separatists' and certain communities in the name of a secularism of
social control (13).
State control of public policies related to sex education is all the
more unsettling in these times of rumbling warfare. "Demographic
rearmament" for the purposes of a war economy could well come at the
cost of a decline in women's knowledge about reproductive control, which
would involve, among other things, an attack on the EVARS (Education for
All Sexual and Reproductive Health). From a purely immediate
perspective, any reactionary backsliding on this issue must be fiercely
defended (see the infographic "Education: The Anti-EVARS and Anti-Gender
Crusaders"). But from a revolutionary perspective, as with abortion, we
would also be wise not to place all our hopes on the state guaranteeing
women the keys to their sexual emancipation. Didn't many women's groups
in the 1970s value self-education?
zyg, September 2026
Notes
(1) "Should we destroy public services?", Courant Alternatif 358 March 2026
(2) French Institute of Education and ENS de Lyon, 2016. IFÉ Monitoring
Report No. 112: The education of girls and boys: paradoxes and
inequalities .
(3) Rebecca Rogers, Coeducation: Past and Present Issues , ENS de Lyon
editions, 2004 and Coeducation in Europe , Encyclopedia of Digital
History of Europe, 2020
(4) Education: A Means of Integration or Emancipation?, Courant
Alternatif Special Issue on Schools, 2011
(5) See the website incendo.noblogs.org, on the links between gender and
class
(6) Geneviève Pezeu. Girls among boys: the beginnings of coeducation in
French secondary schools from the 1920s onwards . Bérangère Kolly. Sex
and Education , 5, Transverse, 2014
(7) Cited in Balls on the Table , Victoire Tuaillon, 2019
(8) Nicole Mosconi, Gender and School Practices: How to Educate for
Equality?, Eduscol, 2008
(9) Eric Debarbieux, Arnaud Alessandrin, Johanna Dagorn and Olivia
Gaillard, report Gender Violence in Schools , European Observatory of
Violence in Schools, 2018
(10) Sylvie Ayral, The Making of Boys , 2011
(11) DEPP (Directorate for Evaluation, Forecasting and Performance),
2024. Girls and Boys on the Path to Equality. From primary school to
higher education
(12) Yves Verneuil (2025), Sexuality education in French schools from
the beginning of the 20th century to the present day: a socially
sensitive issue . New notebooks of educational research. This section is
largely inspired by this article. For a summary, see Grégory Chambat,
"Évars: a brief chronology", feminist and libertarian journal
Casse-rôles no. 35, February-April 2026.
(13) Simon Massei, Disciplining the suburbs? Gender equality education
gone astray , La Dispute, 2024.
https://www.oclibertaire.lautre.net/spip.php?article4779
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
- Prev by Date:
(en) France, UCL AL #375 - Culture - Reading: Romain Lemire, "Clément" (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
- Next by Date:
(en) Spaine, Regeneracion: Class, autonomy, and the constitution of the revolutionary subject (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
A-Infos Information Center