|
A - I n f o s
|
|
a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists
**
News in all languages
Last 40 posts (Homepage)
Last two
weeks' posts
Our
archives of old posts
The last 100 posts, according
to language
Greek_
中文 Chinese_
Castellano_
Catalan_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
_The.Supplement
The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours |
of past 30 days |
of 2002 |
of 2003 |
of 2004 |
of 2005 |
of 2006 |
of 2007 |
of 2008 |
of 2009 |
of 2010 |
of 2011 |
of 2012 |
of 2013 |
of 2014 |
of 2015 |
of 2016 |
of 2017 |
of 2018 |
of 2019 |
of 2020 |
of 2021 |
of 2022 |
of 2023 |
of 2024 |
of 2025 |
of 2026
Syndication Of A-Infos - including
RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups
(en) UK, ACG: NON-VIOLENCE DOES NOT EXIST (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
Date
Sun, 8 Nov 2026 08:07:23 +0200
The text below appeared in the journal of the Organisation Communiste
Libertaire (OCL) of France, Courant Alternatif. Whilst specific French
instances are referred to, we feel that this is a useful general article
on the question of "non-violence." --- For ages, the debate between
non-violence and violence has permeated social movements. Violence is
not only physical, but also institutional, symbolic, psychological, and
so on. This opposition is largely fuelled by the state. It criminalises
our mobilisations by accusing them of being violent, even going so far
as to accuse them of terrorism or of glorifying it. It is imperative to
move beyond this opposition and try to act by taking into account and
articulating the multiple forms, actions, and initiatives that social
movements take.
The primary function of the state is to maintain social order:
capitalist society. It is founded on exploitation, the maintenance of a
social hierarchy, patriarchy, and the division of the dominated among
themselves, through racialisation, the subjugation of certain genders,
criminalisation, and the creation of artificial competition. All of this
generates daily violent conflict. Faced with challenges to these various
aspects, the state has no choice but to respond violently. In this
context, the debate between non-violence and violence is sterile. It
only serves to perpetuate divisions within social movements.
This violence takes many forms. The first, and most visible, is physical
violence, for which only the state is deemed legitimate. This requires
police forces, and even military personnel if necessary. The judicial
system is one of the tools of this violence. The goal is to crush by
force any form of social protest and to imprison anyone who does not
submit to this social order.
Politically, the bourgeoisie can turn to the most authoritarian
governments when it deems the situation too perilous. Thus, in the
1930s, some capitalists declared, "Better Hitler than the Popular Front"
(for example, de Wendel, a steelworks owner and member of the Comité des
Forges). To analyse the interwar period, the focus is primarily on the
rise of authoritarian regimes in Europe, the most well-known being
fascism in Italy and Nazism in Germany.
From February 1917 until 1939, a revolutionary wave swept across much
of the globe. It began with the Russian Revolution in 1917, followed by
the German Revolution in 1918. This process spread to Italy with the
creation of workers' and peasants' councils and to Central Europe. From
1936 to 1939, Spain experienced the most significant revolutionary
upheaval that challenged capitalist society. The United States was also
affected by this social unrest: numerous factories were occupied by
proletarians who could no longer bear the consequences of the 1929
crisis. This inspired workers in France during the Popular Front, who
also occupied their workplaces. This greatly worried the capitalists. In
France, after initially condemning the Popular Front, they appealed to
Léon Blum, the Prime Minister, to resolve the conflict so that the
workers could "liberate" the factories and return to work.
Governing through fear
Currently in France, entire segments of the population are subjected to
this physical violence. Residents of working-class neighbourhoods are
subjected to it daily. This results in numerous injuries and deaths.
Special police units are assigned to maintain order in these areas. The
State, through the justice system, the administration, and the
mainstream media, attempts to conceal this violence, either by
minimising it or by discrediting the victims and those who express their
solidarity. Legal proceedings can be initiated when individuals,
political groups, or artistic groups declare that the police are killing
people. The State must absolutely normalise this police violence to
maintain fear in these neighbourhoods, keeping residents silent about
their increasingly degraded living conditions. It is a veritable
government by fear that is being established. When some residents
revolt, the repression is extremely violent.
This form of government by fear has been used for several years to
repress social movements (the movement against the El Khomri law, the
Yellow Vests, the pension reforms, etc.). The mobilisations can be large
(involving several million people), but the state responds only with
violence, seeking to crush them by force. It refuses any questioning of
its political choices. Macron clearly demonstrates the purpose of the
state. He governs to satisfy the wealthiest few percentages of the
population and large corporations, primarily multinationals. The rest of
the population must endure the deterioration of public services
(education, healthcare, etc.) and pay for an increasingly unequal
budget. Similarly, the distribution of wealth is becoming increasingly
unequal.
Under these conditions, the state must equip itself to be even more
repressive. Given the deterioration of living and working conditions, he
cannot rule out the possibility that people will organise to oppose
these societal choices, leading to the impoverishment of increasingly
large segments of the population.
But since the state alone holds the legitimacy of physical violence, any
form of popular physical and violent opposition is condemned. Social
movements are delegitimised in order to depoliticise them. They are
often labelled as terrorists. Thus, new categories are invented, such as
ecoterrorism, and more recently, movements denouncing the massacre of
the Palestinian population in Gaza and the West Bank by the Israeli
state are denounced as antisemitic and as glorifying terrorism.
It's only a matter of time before any protest or mobilisation becomes an
act of terrorism! Neoliberalism must prevail at all costs. Thatcher
declared there was no other choice. Clearly, she has descendants!
Challenging this form of capitalism is synonymous with
"lèse-bourgeoisie" (a crime against the bourgeoisie). All means are
justified to maintain the hegemony of the bourgeois class, even if it
means killing people, massacring populations, refusing to eradicate
genocidal processes, even if it means destroying the planet by refusing
to question productivism and thus the creation of ever-increasing profits...
This unconditional support for the apartheid and colonisation policies
of the Zionist state serves to criminalise all Muslims, and by
extension, immigrants of Arab origin. They are portrayed as backward,
wanting to impose Sharia law and challenge "democracy," "equality
between men and women," and even, for some, to "replace" whites with
Arabs, etc. But do we live in a truly democratic country? Are elections
a democratic guarantee? Can we truly take control of our own affairs
within the current institutional framework? Can we collectively
determine what we produce, how, with what means, and for what purposes?
Can we reclaim these questions (currently answered exclusively by
capitalists according to their own interests) to prioritise socially
useful work? Has patriarchy disappeared? Has racism vanished?
Social, institutional, symbolic, psychological violence...
The state and those in power exert other forms of violence. Who hasn't
experienced institutional violence from administrative services, for
example? These services often receive us with suspicion. An unemployed
person is frequently perceived as a fraudster who must be subjected to
increasingly strict controls. A person of foreign origin often faces
racism, contempt, and, again, suspicion. It is becoming increasingly
difficult to assert one's rights, even though these rights are regularly
curtailed by laws.
Providing answers is very difficult due to the isolation of individuals,
while the person they are speaking to relies on the institution for
which they work. In fact, we are confronted with our own solitude in the
face of these state machines. At times, revolts are expressed
individually or collectively. Here again, we are met with authoritarian
responses (police, justice system).
Psychological violence can also be perpetrated, for example, in the
workplace. Employers generally receive state support when employees
oppose them by occupying the company. The police, acting on the
prefect's orders, usually violently remove them, even though they are
fighting, for instance, for their dignity.
Increasingly degraded working conditions are also experienced as
violence against workers. Concretely opposing them can also lead to
repression, often violent. And what about evictions? Finding oneself
suddenly on the street can only be an act of extreme violence. Being
locked up in a detention centre, then forcibly put on a plane while tied
up to be "deported" to a country from which it was deemed vital to
distance oneself, is an act of extreme violence.
We could continue this list of examples of everyday experiences.
This shows how difficult it is to separate all these forms of violence.
Some mutilate bodies, others cause psychological pain. Some inflict
physical blows, others leave no trace on the body. But all are
expressions of a desire to dominate us, to impose the capitalist social
order on us, to humiliate us, to remind us of our status as commoners.
A sterile opposition
We cannot accept the division imposed by the State. On one side,
physical violence, for which only the State has the legitimacy; on the
other, symbolic, institutional, psychological, and other forms of
violence that can be exercised by many, as long as, in certain
situations or thanks to a social status (like a boss, for example, or a
zealous civil servant with a high opinion of their position, etc.), a
person is in a dominant position.
Faced with violent situations, it is difficult to distinguish between
violent and non-violent responses. Faced with violence, all responses
are violent. Whatever responses we give to thugs or directly to
oppressors, they will always be experienced as violent. Whether we go on
strike peacefully (railway workers on strike: that's a hostage
situation!) or hold a boss hostage to obtain a pay raise; Whether we
prevent the deportation of an undocumented immigrant through a sit-in or
by forcing our way through a police barricade, it will always be
perceived as violence on our part.
Rejecting the violence/non-violence dichotomy means rejecting the
categories into which the State seeks to confine us; it means rejecting
the separation between so-called responsible citizens (that is, those
who ultimately accept state violence or violence supported by the state)
and supposed terrorists, to use the vocabulary currently in vogue within
the corridors of power. This allows us to move beyond this sterile
debate, which ultimately only those in political power hold a monopoly
on. The act of mobilising inevitably provokes aggression against those
against whom we mobilise, regardless of the form of mobilisation. The
struggle against exploitation and domination is always violent! The
construction of power relations (doesn't this common expression contain
a form of violence?) requires diverse and complementary modes of action
to impose our demands, but also to envision imaginaries both in everyday
life and to build futures that break with capitalism: creative utopias.
J Christophe
Comment from OCL:
We wish to reiterate that, beyond what the author states, the capitalist
state, whatever its form, is not the only vector of oppression. In
capitalist society, and with Macron's neoliberal policies, which
normalise the state of exception (Article 49.3, state of emergency,
etc.), class violence is experienced daily. It is structural violence,
theorised by Johan Galtung, that produces oppression and inequalities in
access to common goods (healthcare, education, resources, etc.). This
can manifest as joblessness or being trapped in low-paying jobs that
deprive workers of a portion of production for the benefit of the
wealthy. It is also the domination and suffering of the most vulnerable
that the productivist world of work engenders, as developed by Michel
Foucault. It is worth recalling that one of the characteristics of this
structural violence is that it renders the lives of the proletariat
"uncertain" at the intersection of social reproduction, patriarchy,
downward mobility, racism, and class-based racism. In the current
context of radicalised anti-social policies and repression, we are
publishing this perspective on state violence because, in our view, it
reflects questions raised in demonstrations and shared feelings of both
isolation and hope for finding the strength to act. Ultimately, this
text addresses, in its own words, the fact that the state has succeeded
in imposing the "collective belief" of Max Weber's "monopoly on
legitimate physical violence", but also the symbolic violence so dear to
Pierre Bourdieu. This text also questions the notion of non-violence and
moves towards the notion of counter-violence, which liberates, as
opposed to the oppressive, dominating violence of Herbert Marcuse .
Questioning these concepts seems to us a necessary step to re-establish
more solidarity, which in our view can only be revolutionary.
https://www.anarchistcommunism.org/2026/10/13/non-violence-does-not-exist/
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
- Prev by Date:
(en) France, OCL: Blog publishing banned - The Internet, "a space of freedom", really? by Saint-Nazaire (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
- Next by Date:
(en) Greece, APO, Land & Freedom: Athens, These are not accidents - State and capital are murdering workers (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
A-Infos Information Center