|
A - I n f o s
|
|
a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists
**
News in all languages
Last 40 posts (Homepage)
Last two
weeks' posts
Our
archives of old posts
The last 100 posts, according
to language
Greek_
中文 Chinese_
Castellano_
Catalan_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
_The.Supplement
The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours |
of past 30 days |
of 2002 |
of 2003 |
of 2004 |
of 2005 |
of 2006 |
of 2007 |
of 2008 |
of 2009 |
of 2010 |
of 2011 |
of 2012 |
of 2013 |
of 2014 |
of 2015 |
of 2016 |
of 2017 |
of 2018 |
of 2019 |
of 2020 |
of 2021 |
of 2022 |
of 2023 |
of 2024 |
of 2025 |
of 2026
Syndication Of A-Infos - including
RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups
(en) France, OCL CA #363 - Management in National Education and Resistance (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
Date
Sat, 7 Nov 2026 09:42:30 +0200
In schools, as elsewhere, neoliberal capitalist logic is invading
professions and bombarding staff with rhetoric and practices that
disorient many colleagues, individualize the relationship to work, and
systematically dismantle collective structures. What is called New
Public Management is, in fact, derived from management practices
invented in the private sector, from which it borrows many
characteristics. This article does not claim to provide a comprehensive
overview of managerial issues in schools and their consequences for all
employees (administrative staff, teaching assistants, special needs
assistants, etc.) (1). It presents the observations and perspective of a
secondary school teacher working in a priority education zone, who also
attempts to incorporate other accounts, particularly from primary
schools. Above all, it also offers stories of resistance to this
ideological steamroller.
Management = a work merry-go-round!
The image of a riding arena is a good way to understand management
because its primary function remains, and will remain, to make workers
go round and round within the tightly closed enclosure of salaried and
subordinate labor, at the command-sometimes the whip-of the
trainer/manager. As a definition of management, we can cite that
proposed by Danièle Linhart (2), who speaks of "a systematic
individualization of work, of the management of employees, and of the
organization of their work." Any idea of a professional collective (she
emphasizes professional knowledge, the trade) must disappear, and to
bring it into line, several tools are used, which we will attempt to
list here. From its very origins, management has been conceived as a
weapon of mass destruction against class consciousness and the class
struggle. This is why it was primarily theorized by employers after the
revolutionary ferment of the 1960s and 70s. And it will be put into
practice, starting in the 1980s with what we call the neoliberal
revolution and the bourgeoisie's counter-attack on the working class.
Capital wins the battle, resulting in the objective and subjective
disappearance of the working class and its revolutionary projects. Even
today, work is no longer radically criticized by the workers themselves.
Only managers continue to take work seriously, in order to perpetuate
the conditions of exploitation and intensify the extraction of surplus
value. But let's get back to school...
Evaluation at all times and at all levels
This is THE way to individualize education workers, and this is
achieved, up until compulsory schooling at age 16, through national
student assessments. It's also worth noting the national diploma, the
Brevet, taken in 9th grade, which, incidentally, is not a diploma whose
attainment determines further studies. In any case, it remains a
milestone in national assessment. We won't discuss here the subsequent
student assessment process with Parcoursup in high school, where, in
addition to the constant monitoring of student grades, the student
becomes, at age 16, an entrepreneur responsible for their academic career.
National assessments have been systematized since 2017-2018 with the
Blanquer reforms. They take place every year for all levels of
elementary school (grades 1-5), as well as grades 6, 7, 8, vocational
10, and the first year of vocational training (CAP). Only mathematics
and French are tested in a highly standardized format: in elementary
school, in the form of a booklet; In secondary school, this takes place
digitally on a computer. Each time, for one hour, the student must
answer a series of questions as quickly as possible. The format itself
raises concerns about student stress, the multiple-choice format, and
the sometimes inconsistent use of technology. The underlying principle
is a standardized approach to education where the emphasis is solely on
skills, which have become the central theme of school learning.
Knowledge and information are deemed useless; only the student's ability
to adapt to a situation matters-this is referred to as know-how and
interpersonal skills. Skills are defined as a list of tasks to be
completed: knowing how to write, knowing how to count, knowing how to
read fluently (reading time is timed!), and so on.
This mass of information, this data (!), is uploaded by teachers into
software programs and processed by the administrators of the National
Education system, who are located in regional education authorities and
academic inspectorates. It's worth noting that in primary school,
teachers are responsible for manually correcting and entering students'
answers. To ensure public acceptance, feedback is provided to parents,
who can track their child's progress year by year with attractive
"spider web" diagrams. From a pedagogical standpoint, there are always
colleagues who will find it wonderful to have an annual, personalized
overview of their child's mastery of the "fundamentals." But this
overlooks the central function of national assessments: the
administrative management of data, where it becomes easy to rank
schools, teams, and teachers against each other, and by extension, to
judge academic performance, which often reflects the parents' social
standing. You have millions of records at your disposal. Ultimately, it
is through the students and these national assessments that teachers
themselves are evaluated. Management, through the academic inspectorate,
will then be able to "differentiate" in order to better atomize
individuals. But before seeing how this systematic division is achieved,
let's look at some other magic words of school management.
The objectives, the contracts, the projects
Management (another magic word) by objectives and contracts was
initiated as early as 1989 by the Education Act (Jospin Law), initially
aimed at promoting autonomy and local adaptation of schools. Even then,
neoliberalism was already influencing social democracy... School and
institutional projects for secondary education emerged.
Contractualization became widespread in 2005 with the Fillon Law and
again in 2013 with the Education Reform Act, once more under the
leadership of the Socialists during Hollande's presidency. This latter
law truly established performance contracts and educational pathways for
secondary education, encompassing four themes to be addressed in each
school, in addition to traditional subjects. These themes are: future,
for student guidance; citizenship, for instilling civic responsibility
and liberal democracy; health, for all medical and social services for
children and their families; and arts, with an opening to the world of
culture.
The school development plan is a mandatory document that outlines the
implementation of national educational programs over three to five
years. It is adopted by the school board. It includes academic
activities-with an emphasis on skills (know-how and interpersonal
skills)-but especially extracurricular activities, including the
well-known learning pathways, as well as various initiatives addressing
school climate, dropout prevention, school-family relations, and, more
recently, the fight against bullying. Ultimately, the school development
plan must be a comprehensive and innovative program designed to promote
student well-being, strengthen ties with the school's community
(including local partners), and support staff, who can request training.
The entire plan must be quantified using qualitative and quantitative
indicators and then evaluated at the end of the contract. It's a complex
undertaking that requires teachers to attend at least four meetings in
the evenings after school. As an aside, when drafting the last school
contract where I work, the headteacher put us in a group with a
secretary, while simultaneously authorizing and strongly encouraging the
use of artificial intelligence. Another anecdote: during an evaluation
of a performance contract by an "audit" team made up of inspectors and
school principals, the rapporteur asked everyone, in front of them, if
the teaching staff were coping with the hyperactivity of the projects
and other initiatives mentioned above. Well, the answer was no, they
weren't coping anymore!
The final element of the "new public management" triptych: the project!
Just like in any private company or local authority, teachers are
encouraged to submit projects if they want to "explore" educational
pathways or simply do something different, like lunchtime and
after-school clubs. This involves writing action plans or responding to
calls for projects from other public bodies such as the town hall, the
Regional Health Agency (ARS), etc. At the end of the year, reports must
be written and presented at the final General Assembly before the
holidays. In priority education zones, since 2019, there have been
"educational cities - for a label of excellence"-the jargon is something
to behold! This involves bringing together the prefecture, the school,
and the municipality around schools located in Priority Neighborhoods of
the Urban Policy (QPV). The goal is to be as efficient as possible in
"managing projects and sharing resources." Several times a year, the
three parties meet as a "troika"-the Greeks will appreciate the
reference! It's at this meeting that projects are discussed, compared,
and funded. Initially, there were many resources available to encourage
teacher participation. Seven years later, the coffers are empty, and
there's talk of them disappearing altogether. But the underlying logic
remains, permeating the teachers' minds. In my school, a silent
competition has developed between projects like gardening, choir, and
dropout prevention; all of which clash with academic subjects because
class time is lost to these initiatives, for example. Ultimately,
tensions arise and fuel resentment, which can prevent collective action
and activism. Not to mention the entrepreneurial spirit that has taken
hold of some colleagues who create websites, publish YouTube videos, and
cultivate their own little educational businesses. Long live the startup
school!
The multiplication of tasks: towards a Taylorization of teachers?
As we've just seen, teachers today are expected to be more than just
educators; they're expected to be capable of many other things, even
without being involved in a specific project. The role of the lead
teacher then becomes particularly demanding when it involves managing
educational pathways, the transition from primary to secondary school in
6th grade, career guidance from 8th grade onwards, sex and relationship
education (EVARS), not to mention the files for students with special
educational needs (EBEP): PAP, PPS, PPRE, Gevasco (just mention these
terms to teachers, and you're guaranteed a reaction!). But national
assessments-and we could also mention the PISA rankings each year-also
require schools to be more effective in the fundamental skills of
writing, reading, and arithmetic. We are thus faced with contradictory
demands that subjectively create insecurity for teachers.
It is based on these observations that some speak of a Taylorization of
the teaching profession (3). According to Frédéric Grimaud, the
Taylorization of teachers rests, on the one hand, on job insecurity with
the continuous deterioration of working conditions (number of children
per class, imposed overtime), the increasing precariousness of careers
and employment statuses within the National Education system, and the
decline in salary levels (freezing of the index, stagnant wages).
Regarding the objective precariousness of the school system, it is worth
noting that there are increasingly more contract teachers and support
staff. According to official figures (DEPP, 2024): out of 1.2 million
workers, approximately 22% are contract employees, including around
40,000 teachers, 60,000 teaching assistants, and 135,000 other staff
(1). The National Education system is by far the largest public employer
of precarious workers. On the other hand, Taylorism occurs through the
deskilling of teaching, which results from the increasing imposition of
ministerial directives on content and practices; the use of standardized
methods and assessments that often rely on "science," particularly
neuroscience; and the proliferation of standardized assessments as a
control mechanism (see above).
Two examples illustrate this point. In primary schools in priority
education zones, teachers are required to follow the reading method
implemented by the association "Agir pour l'école" (Act for School), a
creation of the Axa insurance group. Everything is delivered ready-made,
including the assessments! Regarding the proliferation of ministerial
directives: if we refer to the Education Code created in 2000, this law
has been constantly amended. Barely a fifth of the thousands of articles
that structure the French school system have remained unchanged for
twenty-six years. During this period, 20% were eliminated, 17% were
added, and over 40% were modified, some several times. The period with
the most change coincides with Macron's first five-year term. And this
doesn't even include the constant revisions to circulars, decrees, and
the numerous reforms initiated by one minister and dismantled by
another. In 10 years, there were 9 different Ministers of National
Education!
Command and training
In a highly managed school system, the power of principals increases
while the number of junior managers proliferates. Since the PPCR
protocol (Professional Pathways, Careers and Remuneration) - a word that
seems to have resurfaced during the height of the Covid pandemic -
school principals share 50% of their evaluations with the inspectors.
Teachers are interviewed by the principal for an hour, which we are
asked to prepare for beforehand by completing an official document
outlining the "teacher reference framework." The hierarchy inquires
about professional skills, motivation, involvement in the school, and
career prospects. This entire process culminates in an assessment and a
grade based on a sufficiency scale. However, unlike other employees,
teachers are only evaluated at three stages of their career (the pay
grades). In primary schools, there is no direct hierarchy in the
workplace, but rather a more distant one led by a district inspector
(IEN), who nevertheless seems to conduct more visits and training
sessions. As for school principals, their status changed in 2023, when
they became functional but not hierarchical superiors. Nevertheless,
they are taking on a greater role in the management of the school and
its teams, which is not without creating tensions.
One level below, there are the mentors or coordinators, very common in
priority education zones. These are people who receive reduced teaching
hours and/or additional compensation to carry out "missions" related to
educational pathways and to oversee an entire grade level, such as all
the sixth-grade classes. They meet with school principals regularly to
review progress and report back. On the colleagues' side, they send
information and propose action plans for the various pathways. This
creates hierarchical situations among colleagues, and tensions often
arise. People who accept these roles do so for several reasons: genuine
commitment to education; less time spent in front of students; a change
of profession; career advancement. At the end of the chain, if you don't
cooperate enough, if you complain, or if you struggle with the increased
workload, your more or less supportive manager will offer you training.
This is particularly noticeable in primary schools because teachers must
complete 108 hours per year outside of class time for professional
development, including almost mandatory training. These methods vary in
their top-down approach, but all aim to gain the support of the
individual in question. This can be achieved through games, relaxation
time (true story), and "open discussion" sessions. Group work plays a
significant role, with a system of secretarial support and reporting to
ensure everyone's involvement. In priority education zones, there is one
to one and a half hours of weekly planning meetings, while training
sessions take place on Wednesday afternoons or evenings via
videoconference. These sessions are facilitated by principals,
designated colleagues, or external representatives from associations or
the regional education authority. Even though these planning meetings
are not mandated by law-a formal assignment order would be
required-principals keep track of attendance and then approach absent
colleagues to inform them of their absence and thus put pressure on them
for the next one. Fortunately, in this dreary and exhausting management
landscape, there is resistance and sometimes a desire to rebuild a sense
of collective responsibility when everything is geared towards
individualization. Here are two struggles in middle school and
elementary school.
Resistance to the "improving school" program
Here again, we can appreciate the linguistic contortions, as this is a
"program" for schools where 40% of students have an average below 8/20
on the national diploma exam in mathematics and French. This is the
latest brainchild of the new Minister Geffray, who simultaneously
announces that he will not be implementing any reforms under his own
name... In reality, it's an austerity-driven response to the issue of
priority education and the lack of revision to the resource allocation
map, which hasn't changed in 11 years. A school in a priority network
benefits from several advantages, such as: a degree of autonomy in its
teaching hours allocation, a normally lower class size, a weighted
workload, financial compensation in the form of a bonus, and
preferential treatment for transfers. Instead, the current government is
applying management principles to the letter: do more with the same, or
even less, because, as Minister Geffray has stated, the "improving
school" program is not intended to provide additional resources; the
problem, he claims, lies in the teaching methods employed by the teams.
Thus, 800 middle schools in France will have to conduct a "shared
assessment" and develop a "three-year, multi-year roadmap, with clear
progress objectives and monitoring indicators." This will take place
over four half-days of "implementation," all under the auspices of an
"Academic Committee for Fundamental Knowledge" led by inspectors. In
practical terms, we are being told to requisition four half-days at the
end of the school year, when the curriculum for the final year of middle
school and the national diploma exam (brevet) needs to be completed. The
first sign of frustration. The details of the plan are the final straw:
"small group work on targeted skills; the possibility of developing
co-teaching arrangements in classrooms; enhanced support in French and
mathematics; tutoring, mentoring, homework assistance, success programs;
initiatives focusing on school climate, health, and communication with
families."
In May, two inspectors at my school showed up with charts of figures,
telling us things were good but could be improved. The attack wasn't
direct, of course; it was all about suggestion, listening, and being
kind-how awful! The message was even harder to swallow because we'd lost
a class with resources, and a teaching assistant position was also being
eliminated. We were told it was due to declining enrollment, but when we
calculated the H/E ratio (hours per student), which measures the level
of teaching support, it was decreasing year after year. But we weren't
about fighting a numbers game; during our union time off, we decided to
boycott the meeting. We collectively organized a press release and
sabotaged the meeting by speaking after the principals and inspectors
had introduced themselves. After highlighting the lack of resources and
the contradictory instructions, we invited our colleagues to leave the
room for an inter-staff general assembly, as the teaching assistants and
special needs assistants were also present. Three-quarters of the room
stood up, and we had one of the best workplace general assemblies I've
ever attended. Each profession was able to voice the problems they
encounter daily at work, and ideas were proposed for improving
collaboration, but above all, for challenging management's leadership
style. The strategies of dividing the team and individualizing staff
were particularly discussed, and it was decided to hold only plenary
general assemblies during scheduled consultation times until the end of
the year. This created a positive dynamic and succeeded in shaking
things up with our administrators, at least until the start of the new
academic year.
At the September pre-term meeting, the reaction was swift. Barely had
the pleasantries about "how were your holidays?" been exchanged when the
administration imposed the dreaded disciplinary sessions we hadn't
wanted in May. Caught off guard, the group didn't know how to respond to
this attack, and we went to different rooms with forms to fill out on
harmonizing our teaching practices. During the morning, gradually
emerging from our summer lethargy, we asked questions about the purpose
of such documents and their connection to the "School in Progress"
program. We were told that it wasn't related at all. However, we learned
that the subject inspectors would be coming two weeks later to meet with
the teams to "exchange ideas" on the completed forms. The trap was too
obvious, and during a union meeting, we were able to regroup and discuss
this issue. With the parents' association - whose members are being
manipulated by the administration - we were able to coordinate our
efforts and decide to hold a one-day strike and a "school strike" to
protest the loss of a teaching assistant position and the "Schools in
Progress" initiative. Unfortunately, the strike didn't coincide with the
inspectors' visit. Nevertheless, many of us were present at the school
gates, maintaining the picket line, while the vast majority of families
kept their children home. This gives us renewed hope for the future, and
we hope to bring together other schools in the area that are also caught
in the web of New Public Management. It's worth noting that other
schools in the Lille region are mobilizing against job cuts and toxic
leadership, which is a significant change compared to previous years
when nothing really changed before the union-organized back-to-school
period at the end of September. Let's hope this momentum continues.
Resistance to national assessments in primary school
It has existed for several years and is supported by unions. That said,
calls for a boycott are always late, and a determined national campaign
would require real coordination. Nevertheless, in some areas, resistance
to assessments continues, such as in the Boulogne region, where primary
school teachers have refused to submit results for three years. In the
inset, you can read the letter they sent to the inspectorate. For the
moment, they have not faced any repercussions apart from summonses that
have had no consequences. Strength to them and solidarity.
Dear Madam Inspector
of National Education, Dear Director of Academic Services, As with every
new school year for several years now, the National Education Unions are
leading a campaign against the "National Assessments"; you will find
attached the latest press release.
In this context, we support colleagues who refuse to administer these
assessments or to submit the results.
The arguments for refusing them have been invariably the same since they
were imposed without any consultation: they are time-consuming,
standardized, and disconnected from the realities on the ground;
moreover, they are a tool for authoritarian management and for creating
competition between schools and colleagues. Proving to be
anxiety-inducing for both students and colleagues, they contribute to a
continuous deterioration of working conditions and an increase in
workplace stress.
As for the framework, it is based on back-to-school circulars which, in
themselves, have no regulatory value. These assessments are not subject
to any specific decree or order. The "National Assessments" are not
included in the texts defining the regulatory service obligations (ORS)
of primary school teachers.
To complete the picture, the Ministry of National Education itself has
confirmed that the data for these assessments is outsourced to a private
provider and a platform of American origin; therefore, not subject to
the DSA (formerly the GDPR)? At a time when cyberattacks are multiplying
and compromising the data of thousands of students and civil servants,
there is cause for even greater concern. Furthermore, it is astonishing
that the administration provides no information regarding the actual
cost-printing, logistics, etc.-of this operation, which is funded by the
public.
Finally, while there is a regulatory obligation to communicate
assessment results, no official text mandates a meeting with parents at
the end of this specific procedure. Thus, during the CSA-SD meeting of
September 3, 2024, the DASEN (Director of Academic Services) of Vienne,
Mr. Barthélémy, confirmed to our colleagues at Snudi-FO that primary
school teachers could not be required to meet individually with each parent.
Working towards a quality public service, please accept, Madam/Sir, the
expression of our union greetings.
In conclusion
Management has taken root and is now widely prevalent in public schools.
We have tried to analyze the various forms it can take, each time
individualizing the worker and imposing an intensification of work. In a
way, we can observe a Taylorization of the teaching profession, as
indeed of other education professions. This feels very strange to a
large number of teachers who still often consider themselves managers,
outside of the traditional wage system. But after having eliminated the
working class, capitalist management is now targeting lower-level
managers, proletarianizing them, and this is beginning to have a
tangible impact. Suffering at work is a painful discovery for many
colleagues. Sick leave is increasing due to overwork, while colleagues
are increasingly talking about a loss of meaning in their profession.
Former high-achieving students, the majority of teachers are at odds
with the contradictory demands of the administration. Here and there,
this neglect manifests itself in regroupings and struggles against
aspects of management: evaluations, the multiplication of tasks,
individualization, authoritarian bosses, etc. This is the best starting
point for rebuilding collective action around a struggle, re-examining
work, and perhaps even politicizing it. Being revolutionary in all of
this seems detached from reality, and we must start from the ground up.
Unions can also serve this purpose. Nevertheless, it is important to
reinvigorate a radical critique of the school system so as not to fall
into the trap of initial reformist promises. This is neither about
defending a nostalgic vision of public education nor about naturalizing
the school, because it is the product and the matrix of a social
relationship where, broadly speaking, it serves to reproduce the
relationships between classes and to transmit the ideology of the
dominant class (4).
Notes:
1 - AED = teaching assistant, formerly known as supervisors; AESH =
assistant for students with disabilities, formerly known as AVS. The
abbreviations change, but the exploitation continues!
2 - Sociologist, specialist in management and its left-wing critique.
She has written numerous books on the subject, including *The Unbearable
Subordination of Employees* in 2021 and *The Human Comedy of Work: From
Taylorist Dehumanization to Managerial Over-Humanization* in 2015.
3 - This is the thesis developed by Frédéric Grimaud in his book
*Teachers, the New Proletarians?*, published in 2024.
4 - For a radical critique of the capitalist school system, read an
article from CA no. 292 (Summer 2019), available on our website.
https://www.oclibertaire.lautre.net/spip.php?article4776
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
- Prev by Date:
(en) Italy, FAI, Umanita Nova #27-26 - Living with Speculation: Carrara - The Politeama Affair (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
- Next by Date:
(en) France, OCL: Radio: No to a license to kill! (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
A-Infos Information Center